A Green Unpleasant Land

In the course of an impassioned post on abortion recently Digby warned women who think they can just travel to another state should abortion be banned where they live, that it’s naive to think fundie misogynists in government would not outlaw travelling to obtain an abortion elsewhere too.

Want proof? Well here it is, happening in Ireland:

Irish court battle over teenager’s abortion right

· ‘Tragic case’ reignites call for constitutional change
· Doctors say brain impaired baby would live only days

Owen Bowcott in Dublin
Wednesday May 2, 2007
The Guardian

A pregnant 17-year-old in state care in Ireland began a court battle yesterday to be allowed to travel to England for an abortion, as the country’s failure to resolve the ambiguities in its abortion laws threatened to erupt into a constitutional crisis.

The teenager, who is four months into the pregnancy, is seeking an abortion because the baby has got a rare brain condition and will not live more than three days after birth, she has been told.

Identified only as Miss D, the teenager has been in the care of Ireland’s health service executive (HSE), since February.

The government agency has overruled her wish for an abortion in Britain. The young woman’s father is absent and her mother’s behaviour had led to earlier court proceedings.

Abortion in this predominantly Catholic country, where the influence of the church has gradually weakened, remains illegal, with the ban on it written into the constitution. Abortions can only be performed if there is a substantial risk to the mother’s life, which includes the threat of suicide. The law does not permit abortion on grounds of foetal abnormality.

Most women seeking an abortion go to England for the operation. Successive complex cases have led to hearings at the European court of human rights and several divisive national referenda.

Since 2002, three teenagers in care have been allowed to go abroad for terminations.

But the republic’s abortion laws have never been fully clarified. As long ago as 1992, a supreme court judge warned that the failure to introduce proper legislation was “inexcusable”.

Last year a 45-year-old woman lost a case in Europe in which she said she had been denied her human rights because she could not have an abortion on grounds of foetal abnormality. The court dismissed her application saying the issue had not yet been dealt with by the Irish courts.

This latest case, emerging in the opening days of a general election campaign, has prompted fresh calls for constitutional reform.

[…]

The application on behalf of the young woman has been brought by her boyfriend, who is supporting her. The teenager, from the Leinster region, had not considered having an abortion until told about the foetus’s medical condition.

Doctors say the baby suffers from anencephaly, a condition where the front part of the brain is missing. The condition is detected through blood screening. Such children are normally blind, deaf, and unconscious. The high court in Dublin has been told that life expectancy would be somewhere between several hours and, at the maximum, three days.

Miss D’s lawyers are seeking the removal of the restrictions on her right to leave Ireland and the rescinding of a request sent to the Gardai to prevent her travelling abroad.

The legal challenge will be heard at Dublin’s Four Courts tomorrow. Lawyers for the teenager said it was a matter of “great importance” that the case be heard as speedily as possible.

The court heard that the young woman was not suicidal but had not wanted to have an abortion before hearing about her baby’s condition.

[..]

They want to force a teenager to carry to term and give birth to a baby that’s deformed and bound to die. This on the same day that priests and employees of the very Catholic church which is behind this cruel law are found to have been wallowing in even more filth and child abuse than had been previously thought.

That’s the culture of life?

The Catholic church has no moral right to tell any woman anywhere what she can and can’t do with her body, so far as to be able to place restrictions even on her right to movement, over-populated as it is with the emotionally disturbed and criminal perverts.

I cannot think of any other situation in which an organisation proven to have harboured sexual criminals and to have colluded in evading the law to protect its rapists and child molestors from justice is given the legal right to impose its twisted morality on women’s private medical decisions .

I See You Baby, Kicking That Ass

For a Saudi woman to expose the hollow arguments of the Saudi patriarchy head-to-head on pan-Arab television is a very brave thing to do, not just morally but physically. Saudi women have been imprisoned, tortured and executed for much less.

Braver still is to use the oppressor’s own ammunition against him – and win. Saudi newscaster Buthayner Nasser is seen here in a televised debate about women’s role in public life and on tv, very publicly demolishing a male Saudi cleric’s arguments, and doing it in such a Koranically-based, logical and respectful yet totally kickass way that he can make no coherent response.

I defy you to watch this and not feel inspired.


[H/T Tenessse Guerilla Women]

Both those who see the mass of Saudi women as mere mobile, silent draperies with no voices or opinions and those who think that any feminist Moslem woman must ipso facto be automatically pro-western and pro-secular will be much enlightened and informed. Maybe it will also enlighten those self-righteous western feminists who think that they and they alone are the holy keepers of the precious feminist flame and that Moslem women are an ignorant amorphous mass just hanging around waiting to be liberated by the eventual triumph of western cultural values. There are many more ways to freedom than through the East Coast intelligentsia.

The original clip can be found here and was translated and subtitled by the Middle East Media Research Institute, which appears so far s I can tell to be a thoroughly worthy organisation in need of support.

(MEMRI) explores the Middle East through the region’s media. MEMRI bridges the language gap which exists between the West and the Middle East, providing timely translations of Arabic, Persian, and Turkish media, as well as original analysis of political, ideological, intellectual, social, cultural, and religious trends in the Middle East.

They also have a great back catalogue of subtitled clips from Middle Eastern current affairs and news programmes here, well worth looking at.

UPDATE

Good job I qualified that last statement with a “so far as I know” wasn’t it? From comments:

steve Says:

April 18th, 2007 at 8:01 am

Um. MEMRI are the guys whose “translation” was responsible for the whole Apple/Mecca storm in a teacup last year: for a neutral organisation, it’s quite surprising how often their translations make Arabs look bad and Israelis good….
Martin Wisse Says:

April 18th, 2007 at 12:02 pm

Actually, they have long been accused off being a crypto-zionist organisation and there have been times when their translations were …less than faithful to the original, shall we say?

I stand corrected.

Good Friday Comedy Double Triple Quadruple

After I’ve posted this I’m taking this weekend off blogging. The weather is gorgeous: the sky is blue and cloudless, the temperature clement; the garden is full of tulips in statuesque full bloom and all the waterside trees are dressed in a froth of blossom and fresh green. Thanks, global warming! The streets are thronged with what seems half the world’s youth, all en fete in their new spring clothes. Amsterdam has a barely suppressed air of freshness, gaiety and optimism, an all too brief moment in a city than can be so grim, grey and dour.

If I don’t do something a little more life-affirming than ponder death, destruction and the general shittiness of life for a while I swear I’ll rip out the spacebar from this kb and slit my wrists with it. But I didn’t want to just bugger off with no notice and without leaving a holiday treat, so to get us in the proper holiday mood, first up’s a seasonal classic.

(It’s Good Friday – how could I not?)

Staying on the spiritual enrichnment theme, today we’re going to spend this afternoon sitting under a tree at an Amsterdam canalside cafe in between shoe shops, watching the world go by and generally feeling smugly cosmopolitan. I already chose the shoes last week – the shopping is just a formality and an excuse to just loaf about gezellig cafes imbibing the holiday atmosphere. The rest of the weekend, who knows? What does one do when one does not blog?

Next clip is a relaxed chat to go with your hot cross buns (or regional paschal treat of choice should you celebrate Easter) and coffee -here’s some gentle comic iconoclasm from the sadly missed Dave Allen, who’s musing about the story of Adam and Eve:

Since no comedy double seems complete without a third video these days, here’s another and it’s -surprise, surprise – about religion again. I’d been looking for a clip of Louis Theroux’s documentary about the Westboro Baptist Church, which we watched on the BBC last week, when I found this instead: an elder male Phelps (the Phelps are known for their rigid fundyism and er, unique theology) being flirted with by an Australian interviewer who seems to know no fear. “…but they’re just so firm!” Heh.

What’s that you say? You want your Easter egg now?

Sorry, can’t do it – the chocolate clogs up the tubes and besides the Easter bunny has other plans this weekend.

Have a nice weekend – I’ll be back late Monday evening/Tuesday morning, euroweenie time, newly shod and spiritually refreshed.

“Friends” of Israel Court Its Destruction

Heads may be rolling in Washington and it’s certainly way past time. But meanwhile, unnoticed because drowned out by media misdirection, the money and power business is going on as usual.

Real politicking happens safely away from the public gaze, at various conferences, private dinners, seminars and annual meetings, at discreetly-funded thinktanks and euphemistically-named political action committees; what we see in the mainstream media is only barely a quarter of a butt-cheek of the vast, wiggling, high-maintenance rump of the right.

So far there’s always been at least a little cosmetic distance between the big campaign money donors and America’s overabundance of absolutely-gaga, blood & thunder, fundie megalomaniac ‘clerics’. One of the reasons the religious right’ve come so far as fast as they have is that there’ve been buffer zones, like Focus On The Family and the Christian Coalition, to smooth out the hick edges and put an acceptable gloss on the more outre ejaculations of the biblical literalists.

But now one fundie nutjob, John Hagee, has bypassed those usual gatekeepers and power-brokers and gone straight to the big money – of all people, The America Israel Public Affairs Committee.

AIPAC’s recent rapturous reception of this fundamentalist Christian demagogue (whose ultimate aim is to bring about Armageddon, Christian dominionism and the ultimate destruction of Israel itself) is raising eyebrows, to say the least.

The America Israel Public Affairs Committee is a respectable organisation, whatver you may think of its politics. It describes itself as America’s pro-Israel lobby. No shilly-shallying there, no mystery about it: all perfectly above-board. I mean, look who’s big friends with them:

Dick Cheney at AIPAC

This Year’s AIPAC Policy Conference is the Largest Ever

Featured speakers will include Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell and House Republican Leader John Boehner – as well as Vice President Dick Cheney and Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni.

So far, so respectable.

AIPAC have shedloads of money, which they distribute to candidates who’ll urge the US to act in what AIPAC see as Israel’s interests. Because of their cash and big supporter base they have massive clout in US politics. I wrote about them a few weeks ago when both Hillary Clinton and John Edwards made unashamedly martial pro-Israel speeches at AIPAC meetings in the hope of getting campaign funding . (If you’re looking for a change of US policy re Palestine, Edwards or Clinton are not your go-to guys.) AIPAC money’s been behind the most hawkish, neocon Republicans in Congress and the White House and its power is such that it’s received wisdom that a Democratic presidential candidate can’t and won’t win without it. That’s why Clinton and Edwards’re both bending over backwards to prove to AIPAC they can outhawk anyone.

But it matters not how much Democrats declare everlasting loyalty to Israel and swear to take no option off the table in it’s protection – because it’ll never be enough. They’re just insufficiently apocalyptic.

No, Hagee’s the kind of man AIPAC can really get behind:

The Goy Who Cried Wolf
The Israel lobby gives America’s leading Christian right warmonger a warm welcome.
By Sarah Posner

Delegates at the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) Policy Conference were treated to an air-brushed John Hagee last night, primed with his most innocuous talking points and stripped of his most outlandish Armageddon rhetoric. Hagee, the founder of the America’s leading Christian Zionist lobby, Christians United for Israel, left his clumsy exegeses of Biblical prophecy back home in San Antonio. He is well-versed in bringing an audience of several thousand people to its feet, and he knew he didn’t need his slide show of mushroom clouds and world-ending wars to work this crowd.

[…]

n anticipation of Hagee’s appearance at AIPAC’s conference, there has been much discussion about whether Hagee is actually an anti-Semite who blames Jews for the Holocaust yet anticipates their conversion at the Second Coming — and another debate over whether it’s actually good for Israel or the world’s Jews when groups like AIPAC ally themselves with him. But judging from the crowd’s reaction, and that of delegates I spoke with afterwards, none of that mattered. Like other Jewish leaders I’ve talked to about Hagee, the attitude is simply that Israel has very few friends, and it needs all the friends it can get. If Hagee is willing to mobilize hundreds of thousands, perhaps even millions of conservative Christians to the cause, then they’re willing to overlook his eagerness for the Second Coming (when we’ll all become Christians), because it’s just a silly fantasy that won’t come to pass, anyway.

[…]

At a time when the Middle East faces seemingly intractable conflicts with dire geopolitical consequences, the notion that Hagee — whose status is only elevated by invitations like AIPAC’s — is leading a political movement based on nothing more than a supposedly literal reading of his Bible only reinforces the view that the United States is being led by messianic forces at odds with world peace and stability.

[…]

When he does speak to actual Middle East politics, it’s only to encourage the further destabilization of the region. Hagee has been agitating for a war with Iran for well over a year now, certainly not a single-handed effort on his part, nor one for which he would deserve sole blame should it happen. But if it does happen (and some think it already has begun), Hagee most certainly should be blamed for something else: convincing his minions that war is not only palatable, but required by God.

Hagee’s speech, laced with charged comparisons of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to men like Pharaoh, Haman, and Hilter [sic], as well as countless Churchillian references, brought the crowd to its feet. “He’s A-OK,” said one AIPAC delegate who had never heard of Hagee before, adding that he wanted to get one of Hagee’s DVDs for his grandchildren to watch.

Should whichever candidate is successful in the Democratic nomination then go on to win the Presidency this weird and worrying coalition of dominionists and zionists is likely to be their new opposition and that’ll make the whole Clinton perjury flap look like a child’s tea party.

One of the unfortunate blowback effects of this very welcome exposure of Republican party corruption is the hollowing out of the slightly-less-insane rightwing leadership. When a void arises, the loony apocalyptic right is only too ready to step up and fill it.

And we all know how that kind of thing turns out.