Which Is It, Fish Or Fowl?

While we’re at the WaPo, lets compare and contrast two of their articles, one from yesterday and one from today. Note the byline on both. One journalist, two articles, two contradicting stories.

one:


Joint Chiefs Advise Change In War Strategy

Leaders Seek No Major Troop Increase, Urge Shift in Focus to Support of Iraqi Army

By Robin Wright and Ann Scott Tyson,
Washington Post Staff Writers Thursday, D
ecember 14, 2006; Page A01

The nation’s top uniformed leaders are recommending that the United States change its main military mission in Iraq from combating insurgents to supporting Iraqi troops and hunting terrorists, said sources familiar with the White House’s ongoing Iraq policy review.

President Bush and Vice President Cheney met with the members of the Joint Chiefs of Staff yesterday at the Pentagon for more than an hour, and the president engaged his top military advisers on different options. The chiefs made no dramatic proposals but, at a time of intensifying national debate about how to solve the Iraq crisis, offered a pragmatic assessment of what can and cannot be done by the military, the sources said.

The chiefs do not favor adding significant numbers of troops to Iraq, said sources familiar with their thinking, but see strengthening the Iraqi army as pivotal to achieving some degree of stability. They also are pressing for a much greater U.S. effort on economic reconstruction and political reconciliation.

Then take a look at article two:

General Says Army Will Need To Grow

Iraq and Afghanistan Are Straining the Force, Chief of Staff Warns
By Ann Scott Tyson

Washington Post Staff Writer
Friday, December 15, 2006; Page A01

Warning that the active-duty Army “will break” under the strain of today’s war-zone rotations, the nation’s top Army general yesterday called for expanding the force by 7,000 or more soldiers a year and lifting Pentagon restrictions on involuntary call-ups of Army National Guard and Army Reserve troops.

Gen. Peter J. Schoomaker, the Army’s chief of staff, issued his most dire assessment yet of the toll of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan on the nation’s main ground force. At one point, he banged his hand on a House committee-room table, saying the continuation of today’s Pentagon policies is “not right.”

So Ms. Anne Tyson, ace reporter, which is it? Does the Pentagon want more troops or doesn’t it?

And did you not notice that you’d written two contradictory reports for the same paper less than than 24 hours apart? Or is the festive beltway cocktail whirl getting a little too dizzily disorientating?

Read more: US Media,Iraq War, Bush, Washington Post

Stating The Utterly Bleeding Obvious Or Necessary Truths ?

I’m Spartacus, you’re Spartacus, we’re all bloody Spartacus, blah blah blah. Nonagenarian former actor Kirk Douglas, of all people, is attempting to rally world youth to sort out the mess his generation created:

Kirk Douglas calls on youth to stand up and be counted

Dan Glaister in Los Angeles
Monday December 11, 2006
The Guardian

The cleft chin may be familiar to some. But others may have difficulty placing the ageing Hollywood star.

“You may know me,” he writes in an open letter published last Saturday. “If you don’t … Google me. I was a movie star and I’m Michael Douglas’s dad, Catherine Zeta-Jones’s father-in-law, and the grandparents of their two children. Today I celebrate my 90th birthday.”

But Kirk Douglas has loftier things on his mind than summoning up the wind to blow out 90 candles. The man who led the slaves to revolt as Spartacus, the man who embodied the suffering of Van Gogh’s art in Lust For Life is turning his attention to the fate of the planet.

“Let’s face it,” he writes to “America’s young people”, “THE WORLD IS IN A MESS and you are inheriting it.

“Generation Y, you are on the cusp. You are the group facing many problems: abject poverty, global warming, genocide, Aids, and suicide bombers to name a few. These problems exist, and the world is silent. We have done very little to solve these problems. Now, we leave it to you. You have to fix it because the situation is intolerable.”

[..]

Cheers for pointing that out Grandad, we’d never have noticed if you hadn’t said.

I had similar feelings at first on reading recent Digby and Hilzoy posts. Shorter Digby: “America has a class system that’s wrecking the country.” Wow, I thought, who knew? So that’s what all those ads and movies and tv shows are about. Shorter Hilzoy: “The methods used to produce chocolate, gold, diamonds and many other commodities produce human misery and ecological disaster.” Do they really? Well, fancy. Oh, OK, that’s why all those Africans are running away from that misery as fast as they can and making new lives in Europe…

Now I was quite peeved. None of these issues are new or unknown or hidden – anyone outside the US with half a brain and a smidgen of conscience who’s followed current events knows these things, even if not in detail. They’ve been out in the open for a long time in the rest of the world, but Americans are acting as though it’s something newly-dicovered! What do you think all the European and S. American leftists have been telling you all this time? Argh, why are you all so stupid?

I was getting a good head of outraged steam up at this point.

But then I thought, am I just being horribly snotty here? It’s that ‘outside the US’ that makes all the difference in perception. To so many US readers who are just switching on to the liberating idea of online dissenting and blogs the idea that by eating a candy bar they are supporting slavery, for example, must be deeply shocking new information which must challenge their view of themselves and their nation’s way of living in some pretty basic ways.

Similarly the truth about their government’s complicity in the torture and murder of thousands in Chile is shocking the US public following Augusto Pinochet‘s death. The information about how the coup was engineered by Kissinger and other neocons and how Pinochet’s murderous regime was supported by the US is something which has, again, been common knowledge for a long time elsewhere, even in the most remote of places. For example the woman doctor who ran the hospice in Devon where my mother died was raped and tortured by Pinochet’s thugs while working in Chile in the seventies. As a result the US’ role in Chile had massive coverage locally.

But at a national and international level coverage of even the most egregious excesses of the Pinochet regime was constantly downplayed, excused and finessed by the US and UK government/media complex particularly so in the US. American Journalists who didn’t sing the right tune were even disappeared themselves, so it’s not surprising that this is all coming as a bit of a shock to many in Leftpondia.

There are many more such shocks to come too, as the citizenry realises the facts are out there, if you only care to look – take Guatemala, Afghanistan, The Marianas, Diego Garcia or East Timor to name just a few- it’s all there for the knowing. There is a whole other mass of people apart from the liberal left blogerati who can only now, because of the wonders of the internet, find out what has been kept from them for so long. Viewed from this standpoint Digby’s and Hilzoy’s posts are objective, trustworthy and essential guides for people to know where to find what’s been hidden in plain sight, rather than just restatements of received wisdom.

So from my initial irritation and snark I’ve changed my position. Rather than being such a horribly European elitist leftist snot I really should be jubilant to find that after all the chipping away at the tunnel face that others have been chipping away on the other side and we’re about to meet in the middle.

In that light even Kirk Douglas’ slightly bizarre call to arms is actually quite laudable – rarely does someone of his generation actually say ‘Sorry, we were wrong’ and make an attempt, however lame, to put it right.

As my son constantly tells me, it’s all good.

Read more: US media, US politics, Blogs, Kirk Douglas, Augusto Pinochet, Chile, Guatemala, Afghanistan, The Marianas, Diego Garcia, East Timor

A Little Historical Perspective

From Ellis Sharp at The Sharp Side:

Mesopotamia

The people of England have been led in Mesopotamia [Iraq] into a trap from which it will be hard to escape with dignity and honour. They have been tricked into it by a steady withholding of information. The Baghdad communiqués are belated, insincere, incomplete. Things have been far worse than we have been told, our administration more bloody and inefficient than the public knows. It is a disgrace to our imperial record, and may soon be too inflamed for any ordinary cure. We today are not far from a disaster.

T E Lawrence (“Lawrence of Arabia”) writing in The Sunday Times, 22 August 1920.

Ah, how times change.

Read more: Iraq, ISG, Mesopotamia, TE Lawrence

Listen While You Die

Our troops may have insufficient armour and equipment, and may be overstretched to breaking point, but hey, at least their iPods are safe. It’s all about priorities, people:

Gizmodo:

YoTank Military Grade Mp3-Player Cases

Surely everyone out there accidentally detonates their MP3 player from time to time, right? I know I do. The YoTank MP3 player cases are milled from solid blocks of aluminum and can stand a RPG or mortar shell explosion 85 percent of the time. Jokes aside this is actually a good invention for our troops serving overseas that treasure their MP3 players. They make cases for the iPod nano, video, mini and the Creative Zen Vision:M. Prices range from $35 to $75. ? Travis Hudson

iPod, Gadgets, War, Afghanistan, Iraq