Super Cub is a master class in visual story telling

The sheer audacity to start your new anime series with over three minutes of no dialogue, no plot, no story made me fall in love with Super Cub the same way the opening minutes of Wonder Egg Priority did last season.

It’s early morning and we’re in Hinoharu train station on the outskirts of Hokuto City –west of Tokyo, south east of Nagano–, with only bird song audible. As a train arrives, we move out from the station and see how rural the setting already is. Light classical music starts playing as we move away through the town towards a small nondescript apartment building at the out-most edge of town, taking a full minute to get there. We don’t know it yet, but this mirrors the daily commute of our protagonist to her school, during which she will tells us that the road to school has a bit of an incline near the station, as we see her struggling to get up the hill. She’ll also tell us that she doesn’t parents, friends or hobbies. For the moment though we don’t even know she exists, as we make our journey through her town.

This is what Scott McCloud, in Understanding Comics called an aspect to aspect transition: “(it) bypasses time for the most part and sets a wandering eye on different aspects of a place, idea or mood”. In anime this sort of transitions are often done the way they are done here, by showing a series of essentially static (landscape) shots, the camera travelling through them, but with little no motion visible, nor people. It’s a way of slowing the viewer down and is most often found in socalled iyashikei, or ‘healing’ anime. Landscape and setting before plot or characters.

The first shot inside the apartment is a classic Japanese ceiling light, ugly and cheap. The apartment is in shadow, no light visible, the walls and ceiling beige and slightly grungy. There is morning light coming in from the kitchen window. The kitchen itself is as utilitarian as the ceiling light: two gas hops, a sink and a fridge, with stainless steel racks hanging from the ceiling with a few cooking pans. The camera turns and shows a microwave and rice cooker on a side table, with the dining table visible in the foreground. The camera moves on to a set of light blue curtains through which a bit of light is showing. School books on a desk are shown as we hear an alarm clock going off. The alarm clock is shown on a bed side table, with a hand coming into frame to shut it off. As it’s stopped, the music stops as well.

Again, an aspect to aspect transition, giving us an impression of the place our protagonist lives in. It’s shabby, it’s small, with few amenities and no visible luxuries. The only real spot of colour in the whole apartment are the school books. The lightning is natural, subdued and of a quality we seldom see in anime. The detail and care with which the flat is rendered lends it a kind of beauty. These shots reveal a bit of the character that inhabits the apartment. Poor, but tidy, with everything in its place, no clutter, an ordered existence.

As our protagonist wakes up –who as of yet has no name– we follow her through her morning routine. We get a glimpse of her as she sits up in bed, then see a badroom door with the sound of a running shower. A glass is put down on table and juice poured in. A piece of bread is smeared with what looks like butter. Finally, a middle distance shot that shows a girl dressed in a school uniform, standing behind a small dining table, with only one chair. It’s the first shot both of our protagonist and her apartment, showing clearly that his is indeed very small, with the kitchen, living room and even the bedroom being all in one room, only the bathroom separate. When the fridge is opened to take out a jar of tea, you can see the light blue curtains that hang next to the bed in the background.

Super Cub: a small grey apartment with in the middle a small grey protagonist

Everything in not just the apartment, but also our protagonist’s routine, is utilitarian, sparse, simple, perhaps out of necessity, perhaps out of character, perhaps both. Her lunch is a simple bento of plain rice, a jar of tea and some sort of instant snack yto go with it. The way she efficiently puts together her lunch and puts it in her school bag shows how routine this is, that she has had to do this for herself for a long time. No elaborate side dishes here, because why would you if you’re just doing it for yourself. She makes her lunch because she has to eat something, not to show off. That is reserved for the animation itself: I could Feel that extra hard twist at the end as she screwed on the lid on her thermos flask. The animation is as understated as the rest of the episode, but simple little things as the way with which she scopes up rice is animated show a quiet competence, an eye for detail again.

Skipping ahead, some seven and a half minutes into the episode, is when everything changes. Seeing it in isolation like this, it’s an obvious trick, especially with that one music note to underscore it. When I was watching it last night though, I knew something had changed, but it registrered more subconsciously than consciously. The story had me fully entranced, all thanks to the confidence with which the animation told it. With a lot of series, we would’ve had flashbacks, or prologues establishing why our protagonist lives her life the way she does. Here we get one small internal monologue as our protagonist cycles to school, laments the incline leading up to it and matter of factly states that she has no parents, hobbies, friends or goals. Even the manga version had the obligatory scene establishing why she had no parents; the anime trusts the viewer to draw their own conclusions. We never even learn her name except that she has to fill it out on the receipt when she finally buys her Super Cub. It takes the original story and parses it down to tell it as economically as possible. The squashed, flattened aspect of the animation fits the squashed, flattened character of the protagonist. The fun is in imagining how the series will evolve from here, as she starts to develop and grow.

Koikimo & Higehiro: adult men chasing high school girls is romantic, right?

In Koi To Yobu Ni Wa Kimochi Warui, it is the pureness of the school girl protagonist that makes the adult co-lead want to pursue her:

Koikimo: a grown up man proposes to a high school girl

Amakusa Ryo is a womaniser who one day leaves the apartment of his latest one night stand without breakfast. He gets dizzy trying to walk down the stairs towards the subway and is saved from falling by Arima Ichika, who also ends up giving him her lunch. When the two unexpectedly meet again because it turns out she is a friend of his younger sister, he tries to reward her by offering to sleep with her. She refuses and he is smitten by her purity and declares her his one and only. From there on he starts wooing (from her point of view, harassing) her through gratitious romantic gestures. And that’s the premisse of the series. He tries to flirt with her, she finds it disgusting, hilarity ensues. She by the way is the only one bothered by all of this. His sister supports his advances and even helps him, her mother finds it all charming that she gets flowers from a mysterious lover.

Higehiro: I will let you do me, so let me stay

In Hige wo Soru. Soshite Joshikousei wo Hirou, salaryman Yoshida, fresh from being rejected by his crush, stumbles across a high school girl, Ogiwara Sayu, near his home, who promptly offers to “let him do her” in exchange for a place to stay:

Yoshida is not that kind of man however. He lets Sayu stay at his place, but not for sex. Sayu it seems comes from Hokkaido, had run away from home six months ago and had made a habit of sleeping with strange men in return for food and shelter. Yoshida vows to break this habit and rehabilitate her, by doing household chores. I can’t help but feel there are better ways of dealing with this situation. Are there really no social services in anime Japan?

Two series in one season that feature a romantic situation between an adult man and a high school girl. One presents stalking as comedy, the other thinks that trading shelter for sexual favours can be explain by selfishness. Which is worse?

With Koikimo the series at least understands that being romantically pursued against your will by a much older man is scary, even if only Ichika thinks so. Higehiro on the other hand presents an equally uneven relationship as something noble because Yoshida doesn’t immediately wants to have sex. That he still holds power over Sayu because he can withdraw his protection at any moment is never even recognised by the series. Which is worse?

Koikimo continually contrasts the “purity” of Ichika with the supposed nastiness of an adult woman’s sexuality; Ryo seems to hate the women he sleeps with. There’s a scene where one of his past lovers bumps into him and Ichika and warns her about him, but it’s shown as her being jealous, not concerned. Higehiro instead has the high school girl as aggressor, promiscuous, treating sex as a commodity, with the male lead having to train her out of this habit. Which is worse?

For me, it’s the second one. While purity culture is dangerous and obnoxious as well, the idea of a young girl as temptress so universally used as an excuse for pedos that it makes me more uncomfortable. Check out for example the lyrics of this little ditty I listened to by sheer coincidence today:

Thirteen summers past by your door
You think its time to score
Alright but don’t tell all the neighbour boys
Your mamas out of town
Thirteen summers got left behind
The minute you found out
Indeed that your blues eyes could hypnotise
Drive a man insane

That’s “Hold Me Back”, by British prog rock group Patto. And while it is from 1970, that attitude is still alive and kicking today. Again, Koikimo at some level seems to at least understand that a ‘romance’ between an adult man and a high school girl is wrong, even if it calls it “gross” rather than criminal. Higehiro on the other hand seems to say that as long as you don’t immediately have sex with her, you could have a romance like this and not be scum. Me, I doubt it.

Nyanpasu! Non Non Biyori Nonstop — First Impressions

The timeless beauty and horror of the countryside.

I don’t think it’s even possible to be as deeply rural and remote as this in the Netherlands. The village school in Non Non Biyori Nonstop only has five students. Where I grew up there were similar such small schools, but even then the students numbered in the tens. The farms my father’s family ran were a ways away from the villages, but we could still bike to them in less than an hour. The Netherlands just isn’t big enough to have this deep a back country. In any case, such a landscape is probably better enjoyed through anime than by actually living there. The slow, deliberate pace and the beautiful setting are relaxing in twentyfive minute long weekly installments, not so much if I was stuck in it 24/7.

As it is though, Non Non Biyori Nonstop is as calming as its predecessors, a nice way to close out the week with. Renge and the rest of the cast are as charming and funny as ever. No need to watch the first two seasons if you hadn’t already, but why wouldn’t you?

Hortensia Saga: hate bow guy already — First Impressions

This is one of the dumbest fight scenes I’ve seen in anime. A bow is not a gun, son.

Hortensia Saga, which starts with a violent coup, had the misfortune to drop on the day of an actual real life coup attempt, as deranged Trumpists stormed the Capitol, egged on by the man himself. Course, in the anime, the coup was started by a werewolf murdering the king in front of his daughter, while the capital was overrun by actual monsters rather than elderly Mid Westerners prone to heart attacks. The chaos in both cases is the same, though in Hortensia Saga‘s case I blame the writers, as the whole coup makes even less sense than Donald’s failed putsch. You got a rebellious duke transforming in a werewolf and killing the king in front of his daughter. Fine. You got the duke’s soldiers attempting to storm and occupy the capital city. Understandable. Then dozens of monsters are also teleported in, as if the loyalists not have enough to deal with. Okay, so the rebels are evil, makes sense. The princess is rescued and taken to safety away from the capital. Which is what you would expect from this sort of story. A hidden princess leading the rebellion agains the tyrant that slew her father. But then, after the OP has kicked in, we get a recap of what we just saw and it turns out the rebels were driven away from the capital, with the younger brother of the princess crowned king.

Hortensia Saga: the crowning of Mariel's younger brother

Then there really is no reason why the princess should remain hidden, masquerading as a squire to Alfred, the son of the knight killed defending her, now is there? If things are safe enough her younger brother can be crowned king, doesn’t it make sense for her to return? This first episode never makes it clear why Mariel has to keep hiding as Marius, even as it skips ahead four years, with Marius and Alfred now teenagers. Mariel has to stay Marius because that’s what the plot says has to happen.

Hortensia Saga: Marius in trouble

It’s emblemic of the sloppiness of Hortensia Saga as a whole. This is the most generic of generic medievaloid battle fantasy. Based on the battles shown in this first episode, don’t expect any sort of realism or proper tactics, just red shirts being hacked down by the heroes or villains respectively. Every named character will have their own personal super weapon, like bow guy in the video above and they will all be ridiculous. I don’t like any of the character designs, it all looks far too flat and shiny and I got a sneaky suspicion Mariel/Marius won’t actually be the protagonist. Especially because she spents most of the episode being rescued. I’m not really interested in yet another medievaloid generic fantasy series that just takes its setting from every other anime fantasy. Therefore, unless things improve in the next two episodes I won’t bother with this. A disappointment.

(An aside: in Dutch, a hortensia is a type of plant, usually associated with retirement. This does not help me with taking this seriously.)

Maesetsu! — not meant to be funny — First Impressions

Opening the first episode of your series with your protagonists doing an air band version of your opening song at the cultural festival is one thing. Following that up with the main protagonist doing a painfully impression of one anime character imitating another anime character imitating the automatic closing doors of the Tokyo Metro is quite another.

And then the rest of the episode is mostly spent chewing over this failure of a standup routine. The sheer audacity of Maesetsu! had me breathless. None of this was funny by the way, but then I don’t think it was meant to be. Maesetsu! — apparantly the Japanese name for warm up comedians at television shows and such — is about the lives of a group of friends trying to become standup comedians, but that doesn’t mean this is a comedy. Nevertheless, the comedic timing of this scene, if not the skit is impeccable. It’s clear that if this series wants to do comedy, it can. It just choses not to for now.

Deep diving into a joke that will never be more than chuckle worthy at best is a strange way to start a series. Almost as strange as starting it with a five minute digression in how to eat a chocolate cornet. There’s something very Lucky Starish about Maesetsu! indeed. Not only is the manga version drawn by Yoshimizu Kagami, Lucky Star‘s creator, but you may have also recognised the voice of the teacher at the end of the video. Yes, that’s Hirano Aya, Konata’s voice actress listening to a bad imitation of her character doing a bad imitation of another anime character doing an imitation of the automatic closing doors of the Tokyo Metro. Brilliant.

Another thing I liked about this first episode was that I felt like we were dropping in on an established group of friends. There weren’t the usual first episode scenes of characters introducing themselves to each other even though they’d been friends for years. As in the scene above, you get to know them through how they interact with each other. Again, not unlike how Lucky Star did back in the day. Red haired Mafuyu is the ideas woman; blue haired Fubuki tries to implement them. Here they are refining their routine. Mafuyu suggests Fubuki should pause momentarily before responding to her gag. Cue five long seconds of Fubuki doing exactly that. Still not funny, but again not meant to be.

Judging from the first episode this will be a talky series. The character designs are neat, slightly softer and rounder than we’ve gotten used to. But that’s about it for visual appeal. It’s mostly people talking to each other. If you need something to happen on the screen at the same time, this probably isn’t a series for you.