Watching too many kid shows

In this age of simulcasting, when seemingly every anime series is available less than an hour or so after airing in Japan, there’s still a major category of shows that isn’t picked up: kids shows, especially those aimed at girls. Even massive franchise in Japan — Pripara, Aikatsu, frigging Precure don’t get an English language release, subbed or dubbed. (Well, there is Glitter Force, but that uses Precure the same way Power Rangers used its source material, chopped up and Americanised. It’s still a good show, but it isn’t really Precure anymore.) Kid shows then are one of the few areas where, if you want to watch them, you’ll have to rely on fansubs if you can’t speak Japanese and/or can’t watch the original airings.

Luckily there still are a few dedicated groups and fansubbers left devoted to those series, but oh the disappointment when they lose interest in a series you are following. Which was what happened for me with Kiratto Pri☆Chan, the reboot of the Pripara magical idol series, which ended last year after four seasons and some 200 episodes. I was enjoying the new series, but the original translator dropped it after less than ten episodes and the new one couldn’t English very well and in any case also seemed to have stopped doing them. A pity, because I was enjoying it. Kiratto had a bit of a twist on the traditional idol show, as it now revolved around a sort of magical Youtube, rather than performing idol shows. It had still the same beats as its predecessors, but I wanted to see where the series was going with it, but then the fansubs stopped.

Aikatsu Friends is the third iteration of the Aikatsu! franchise: the original series ran for 178 episodes and four seasons and was followed by the 100 episodes Aikatsu Stars, which guydolls in the mix and wasn’t received as well as the original. The latest series is a return to the original formula, with a new idol joining the idol school, teaming up with an already established hot new star, to take on various other idols in friendly competition. The change here is that it’s all about friendship, with the two aimed to become platinum friends and ultimately winning the platinum friends cup to become the top idol team. All this while transforming before performing in a sort of magical virtual reality, as shown above. This and Pripara are series that sort of made idols into magical girls and both originated as arcade video games, where you could unlock new outfits and characters and the like and that’s why each idol has her own transformation cards and usually a favourite clothing line. It’s much less toxic than the actually existing idol industry in Japan of course, but that’s why these series have this fantasy element. If you like magical girl shows like Precure with their devotion to friendship and helping each other overcome your weaknesses, you’ll probably like this too.

Which brings me neatly to the eight hundred pound gorilla of kid shows aimed primarily at girls: Precure, which has been running since 2004 and arguably ran every other kids magical girl series out of business. This year’s series, Hugtto Precure is its fifteenth and therefore an anniversary edition, which has resulted in a couple of guest appearances by the previous Precure. It has also been the most openly queer of all the Precure series, as we saw two posts ago. Sadly the entire Precure franchise remains mostly unavailable in the west, but there is the Americanised Glitter Force edit of two of the older series, which is worth watching if you have children in the right age (eight or so) because a lot of the fun of the original is still present in them. Much of what makes the present series so good is the interplay between Lulu, an android who worked for the big evil of the series until she developed an actual heart and Emiru, a slightly younger fan of the Precures who attempted to become one herself; in the end they both became members. Emiru and Lulu went from friends to close friends to an actual couple and they weren’t the only ones: her elder brother became the boyfriend of Henri, the first ‘boy Precure’ as shown in that earlier post.

The one kids show that is easily available over here is of course Pokemon: sun and Moon, which some purists dislike because it doesn’t look like the original, but since I’ve never seen it having been too old for it at the time, I quite like this series. The character designs are cute, it’s not all Ash all the time, the monster battles are more than decent and every few episodes they pull something really weird out of the bag, which is great. I never thought I’d be watching this but here we are, a hundred plus episodes in and still looking forward to it every week.

This is the eleventh post in this year’s twelve days of anime challenge. Tomorrow: Watching too much anime in 2018.

The first boy Precure is genderqueer

Well, it took Henri until episode fortytwo, but they told you so in episode eight:

Hugtto Precure: maybe I will try to be a Precure too

Hugtto Precure is the fifteenth installment in the Precure franchise, which as Andrea Ritsu explains has always been somewhat progressive and queer friendly, especially for a kids franchise. In recent years this has intensified: the Maho Girls Precure protagonists kissed, while there was a canon lesbian couple among the precure in last year’s Kirakira PreCure a la Mode . In this context it would make sense for Precure to finally introduce a boy Precure as well, something with which it has flirted in the past. Not out of some percieved need to always crowbar boys into something intended for girls, but because “boys can be princesses too”. And Henri is the perfect “boy” to do so. After all, they are:

Hugtto Precure: a refined Japanese lady and a Parisian

From their very first appearance it’s clear Henri doesn’t think of themselves as a boy, but as somebody for whom gender is irrelevant, wanting to be both and lucky enough with how they look that they could pull this off. Henri is self assured, confident and completely open in how they perform their gender. Henri starts off as a bit of an antagonist of the Precure girls, being friendly ice figure skating rivals with one of them and thinking the others are holding Homare back. Once that’s resolved though Henri becomes somewhat of a friendly face, helping Emiru standing up to her far too serious brother Masato, who’s obsessed with propriety. Said brother ends up becoming his somewhat over protective boyfriend not to long after by the way:

Hugtto Precure: precious boyfriend

That’s from episode 33 when Henri blows a kiss to their adoring audience and everybody, men and women both, get hearts in their eyes, except for Masato, whose actual heart lights up. It’s a nice touch. In general I like the way the relationship between those two is shown: it’s never spelled out but it’s clear these are more than just friends with Masato always there to help Henri whenever the latter is getting depressed. And Henri does have problems: a potential injury threatens to derail his skating career, while the simple act of growing up, of getting taller, having their voice changed threatens their ability to have the gender they want.

Hugtto Precure: precious boyfriend

Henri isn’t in a lot of Hugtto Precure episodes, but the ones they’re in are some of the best of the series, laying the foundation for their eventual transformation into a true Precure. His story fits the theme of the series, with Henri’s worries for a future in which they may have to leave behind skating. Not to mention the fear that puberty will put an end to their ability to be “both a refined Japanese lady and a Parisian” as their body grows more masculine. The villains of the series too are obsessed with the future, wanting to stop time because only that way will people be unable to feel any more pain. They try to seduce Henri with this shared fear of the future and almost succeed, until:

Hugtto Precure: Cure Infini

Becoming a Precure doesn’t solve Henri’s problems or fears, but it gives back hope, a way for Henri to fight through his momentary depression at losing his skating career and see new possibilites again. Having Henri, somebody who struggled not with who they wanted to be but with being able to keep being that person as the first ‘boy’ Precure fits with the whole ethos of the franchise. Of discovering yourself, of finding new ways to be yourself if the old way no longer suffices. Had they just plunked in some random guy this wouldn’t have worked, but with Henri you have somebody who is queer enough to be a Precure, who can serve as a bit of a role model for all boys to know that they too can be princesses, without having to fear Precure will be remade to appeal more to boys in general.

This is the eight post in this year’s twelve days of anime challenge. Tomorrow: I watched way too many pretty boy series this year.

Why Precure is more mature than Graham Linehan

When a children’s anime series is more kind and insightful than the whole of socalled “gender critical” Twitter put together:

Hugtto Precure: boys can be princesses too

It all started with episode eight of Hugtto Precure, with the introduction of Wakamiya Henri, an ice skating friend of Kagayaki Homare who likes to wear dresses and who described himself as “both a refined Japanese lady and a Parisian”. Little fuzz was made about this, the real conflict that episode was about Henri wanting to take Homare back to figure skating full time. At the end of the episode he decided he would hang around alittle bit longer and transferred into the Precures’ school, but so far little more had been done with him. Until episode 19.

Hugtto Precure: girls cannot be heroes?

Episode 19 also sees the return of this asshole, the brother of Aisaki Emiru, the Precure fan who likes to hang around with Lulu. Last time we saw him, in episode 15, he was telling Emiru she couldn’t play the guitar. This time he’s telling her that girls cannot be heroes, as well as getting shook by seeing Henri wear a dress. Basically, he is the voice of conventionality in these two episodes and in both he’s quickly proven to be wrong. Girls can be heroes, boys can be princesses. Now of course Precure doesn’t use words like genderqueer or trans to talk about Henri, but just seeing a cool, handsome boy like Henri comfortable in his dress, unbothered by the censure of people like Emiru’s brother, in fact convincing them they’re wrong, is a great example for the young girls (and boys!) that are Precure’s primary audience. Such a contrast to the carrying ons of Graham Linehan, once best known as the writer behind Father Ted, currently best known as a transphobic asshole:

Graham Linehan being transphobic on Twitter

That’s him talking about trans men getting top surgery, as if there’s a cabal of trans people out there that takes innocent little butch girls and forces them to become men. Reality is of course that getting any help with physically transitioning is difficult enough for an adult and almost non-existent for those under eighteen. Note btw that his original example was of somebody in their mid twenties, hardly a child. How different this hysteria is from the calm acceptance of Precure. And no, people like Linehan may wring their hands about “unnecessary” surgery, but they don’t condone more “innocent” forms of genderplay either. Men or trans women dressing in female coded clothing: must be predators. Women or trans men dressing butch: must be brainwashed. Anything that doesn’t strictly adhere to a binary worldview where there are only men and women is suspect.

Cervical screening (or the smear test) is relevant for everyone aged 25-64 with a cervix. Watch our animation to find out what to expect when you go for screening

Case in point: this innocent tweet by UK Cancer Research, calling on everybody with a cervix to get themselves tested. Oh, that got the transphobes out in force. Starting with Labour (!) MP Anna “dumb dumb” Turley asking why have you used the term ‘everyone with a cervix’ in this tweet please? Because god forbid we pay attention to trans men or genderqueer people who may have a cervix but aren’t women. Better to use women and ignore that not all women, not even all cis women even have a cervix and need this test. Maybe you’ve already had cervical cancer and had to have it removed. But either these people don’t realise this or they don’t care, because keeping UK Cancer Research tweets ideologically pure is much more important.

So yeah, if you’re looking for understanding and acceptance, don’t look to media personalities like Linehan, look to an anime series aimed at young girls.

How is Precure so good?

No really? How is Precure this good?

Hugtto Precure: no eggs no life!

To recap: Precure is a long running series of magical girl shows that has put out a new series each year since 2004 following roughly the same formula each time, though each series bar two stands on its own. There’s a team of two or more young teenage girls who’ve gotten Precure powers from a magical talking animal mascot to defend the Earth against some sort of primordal evil, which mainly manifests in fighting the monster of the week while also having to deal with more mundane problems. For more detail, see my review of Fresh Precure, which aired in 2009. Hugtto Precure is the latest installment, started last February and so far has been rather good, episode four being a particular highlight, but I think this week’s episode topped even that one.

Sakugablog has the nitty gritty of just who is responsible for making episode fifteen so great and mentions that this is actually supposed to be a budget saving episode. Which just goes to show talented creators can do a lot even under strict limitations. But what sets this episode apart from regular episodes is not just the good use of limited animation, but the focus on two supporting characters. There’s Lulu, the enemy infiltrant now living with main Precure Nono Hana, who is sent out to buy eggs and runs into Aisaki Emiru, first seen in episode nine, who introduces herself as Cure Emi-ru protecting the world through careful prevention. Emi-ru is great, trying to do all the usual stuff Precures do, in which the show obliges her by using the same musical and animation cues it uses for the real Precures. Intrigued, Lulu follows her (or rather, Emi-ru keeps clinging to her warning her of increasingly unlikely dangers she could encounter as she makes her way to the supermarket to buy eggs) and watches as Emi-ru attempts to help people and fails. Lulu then points out that even if she failed, at least she made the people she helped happy.

Lulu and Emi-ru hit it off immensily and it’s great seeing the fired up Emiru trying to explain things to the stoic Lulu. As the former keeps going into these flights of fancy, the latter keeps shooting her down, but not in a mean way. Rather, she seems genuinely concerned for her when her brother comes in to lecture Emiru on how it’s improper for girls to play the guitar. Lulu defends Emiru by continuing to ask him who died and made him boss as well as why playing the guitar is unseemingly, doing that in the same cold, logical way she has done everything this episode. Only when the brother flees, does Lulu reveal some genuine emotion and upset. Which also leads to the most adorable pout in Precure history.

Hugtto Precure: Lulu pouting

The stoic, logical, emotionless girl is a staple in anime ever since Neon Genesis Evangelion. But what struck me here is how much characterisation and character growth the series could put in one episode. There had of course been hints before that Lulu wasn’t as emotionless as she first seemed and she’s a prime candidate for mid-series conversion to the good side, but in this episode we learned she had a sense of humour, was able to make friends and get angry on their behalf and it all happened naturally. That’s what makes this such a good episode even without the brilliant animation to go along with it. Both Lulu and Emiru gained a lot of depth in what was nominally a gag episode and while this episode was incredibly funny, it also adhered to the standard formula of a Precure episode, showing how much the staff could fit in its limitations.

A refined Japanese lady and a Parisian — Hugtto Precure

In episode eight of Hugtto Precure Kagayaki Homare, the third Precure and super talented figure ice skater is visited by Wakamiya Henri, the Prince of Skating, who comes to take her back where she belongs. It’s not an unusual plot point for a Precure series. There’s always one extra special Precure who is the best at some sport or talent or other, who either gets an offer to go study abroad or gets visited by somebody like Henri, who wants her to stop faffing about and work on her career. Normally that’s good for one episode of angst and nothing more, the guys who visit being little more than good looking cyphers, but Henri is different:

Hugtto Precure: a refined Japanese lady and a Parisian

It may go too far to call Henri trans or genderqueer just for his willingness to dress up in female coded clothing, or for him to talk about himself as “a refined Japanese lady” (yamato nadeshiko), but he certainly seems comfortable being “girly”. There is of course a long tradition in amime of handsome boys being pretty enough to dress up as girls without censure; I liked how it was only the dumb hamster sidekick who mildly objected when Henri came out in a dress with nobody else was bothered. It goes to show how accepting a kid show like Precure can be, when nominally adult anime series can’t get past cheap tr*p jokes. Representation always matters, so to have this sort of thing in Precure, one of the most popular anime franchise in Japan is important. Also, this is interesting:

Hugtto Precure: maybe I will try to be a Precure too

Having Henri stick around as somebody who knows the Precure’s secret, who is portrayed as at least a bit genderqueer and who may want to be a Precure himself? That could be fun. Note that they’re still supposed to look out for the fourth Precure, so it’s not entirely impossible that it would be Henri. In the meantime, for a more general overview of why you should watch Hugtto Precure, watch this video: