Essential Captain America vol 02
Stan Lee, Jack Kirby, Jim Steranko, Gene Colan and friends
Reprints: Captain America #103-126 and more (July 1968 – June 1970)
Get this for: Steranko and the old guard changeth — Four stars
Essential Captain America vol. 2 starts where the first volume left off: with slam bang action by Lee and Kirby. They put poor old Cap through his paces, fighting the Red Skull and his band of Nazi cutthroats, Batroc, the Swordsman and the Living Laser, a robot double of himself, the mighty Trapster and his own worst fears manipulated by Dr Faustus. Lee and Kirby fit a lot in every issue, but keep the subplots to a minimum, the only continuing storyline being the romance of Cap and Sharon Carter. You feel they have a formula here for old Cap that, while not as original as Fantastic Four or Spider-Man could be kept up indefinitely. But then everything changes with #110, when Jim Steranko comes aboard.
You could call Steranko the first Image artist, the first one to make his art more important than the story. If you look at Kirby, even his wildest experiments here or elsewhere are always in service to the plot, with even the splash pages determined by it. With Steranko this is no longer the case. In his just four issues of Captain America he has more splash pages almost than Kirby had over his entire previous run, all more concerned with the Rule of Cool than the demands of the story. In fact, in some cases they work actively against the story, as with the Big Reveal in his last issue. But damn if it doesn’t look gorgeous.
Steranko gets away with that sort of stuff because he’s such a good artist. You remember his covers and his splash pages, but his other pages are gorgeous too. Much more than Kirby or any other artist working back then he also consciously designs his pages and panel layout as a whole. So in the opening page of issue 113, he translates the recap of the previous issue into a television report on the death of Cap, with a page filling shot of the camera man and reporter, a line of inset panels in the shape of tv screens through the middle. Later on he has Madame Hydra recalling her origin, with one big panel at the top of the page showing her in control of HYDRA, followed by a quick succession of smaller panels closing up on details of her face as she looks at the horrifically scarred right hand side of her face (only hinted at), to explode in the last panel, short but wide, as we see she has shattered the mirror. Steranko is great at establishing mood this way, using cinametic influences on the comics page in a way that nobody else does at the time. It brings a grandeur to these somewhat silly stories not seen before or since.
Not that the artist coming after him are bad. There’s two fill in issues by John Romita and John Buscema respectively, before Gene Colan takes over, another great mood artist. He stays around for the rest of the issues reprinted here, which means he’s around for the introduction of the Falcon, another pioneering Black superhero and actually the first proper African-American superhero. He’s introduced here without fuzz, without calling out his Blackness, but just as an ally for Captain America at his very lowest, with the Red Skull holding the reality warping Cosmic Cube, having swapped bodies with him and dropped him back on Exile Island, where his old Nazi “friends” are itching to kill who they think is the Skull. Falcon rescues Cap, Cap returns the favour by training him into a superhero and together they defeat but the Nazis and the Skull…
On a certain level these stories are on the dumb side, pure entertainment without the sophistication of Marvel’s flagship titles. To me that’s part of their charm though. About the only thing that really annoys me here is Cap’s attitude to Sharon Carter, his love interest and SHIELD field agent, who he wants to give up her dangerous work to protect her from suffering the same fate at his old partner Bucky. Male chauvenist pig.