The unbearably whiteness of British literature

The 12 best new novelists look frighteningly white

The BBC is doing another of its tedious “reading is cool and hip and you should read more too or at least watch our programmes about books” promotions. In the process The Culture Show also chose its top twelve new writers and, well, there’s something off about them. It’s not just the facepalmingly awfulness of how the chair of the jury describes what literary fiction is in The Guardian:

What is literary fiction? It is not genre fiction. Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall is a historical novel. Kazuo Ishiguro’s Never Let Me Go was shortlisted for the Arthur C Clarke Award, the leading British prize for science fiction. Yet you only have to think about these two examples to see how they escape their genres. Mantel’s novel revisits the favourite stamping ground of historical fiction – Henry VIII and his wives – in order to rethink what it might be to see events filtered through the consciousness of a person from a distant age. Ishiguro takes a dystopian hypothesis – human clones being bred for their organs – and then declines to put in place any of the sci-fi framework that would allow us to understand how this could be. Indeed, the whole interest of his story is in the limits placed upon its narrator. These are both “literary” novels because they ask us to attend to the manner of their telling. And, despite their narrative demands, they have both found hundreds of thousands of readers willing to do so.

But well, doesn’t that group of up and coming literary fiction writers look a bit white to you? Granted, they all look awfully middle class as well, but BBC and Guardian, so let it go. Is the state of literature in Britain so bad that no promising writer of colour could be found?

(Found via BLCKDGRD.)

4 Comments

  • W.Kasper

    February 27, 2011 at 9:47 pm

    They’re not looking for any writers of colour, nor any from working class backgrounds (with multiculturalism and welfare states being sooo ’00s’ these days). It appears Whiteness is the New Labour. Even liberals like to (covertly) indulge in a ‘backlash’ or two – it plays better with their target market than they’d care to admit.

  • Martin Wisse

    February 28, 2011 at 2:10 pm

    I’m not sure it’s wilful backlash so much as just unconscious blindness to their own point of view and what it excludes. As I’ve experienced myself, it takes effort to include those you normally don’t see and if your reference points are Amis, McEwan and perhaps Rushdi or Zadie Smith, it’s easy to slip in a mindset in which finding 12 white people to represent the future of British literature.

  • Robert

    February 28, 2011 at 5:28 pm

    These are both “literary” novels because they ask us to attend to the manner of their telling.

    Um, what does this mean, exactly?

  • Martin Wisse

    March 1, 2011 at 3:28 pm

    I’ve got no idea. But it seems to translate to “this is literary fiction because I like it”.