Bono: saint or pillock?
Pillock, according to Counterpunch, in this excellent critique of the whole Live 8/Make Poverty History clique and the way it sucks the life out of the real global justice movements, substituting real change for more of the same neoliberalism that caused the problems in the first place:
After all, the danger of NGO-lubricated ideological alignment with the neoliberal forces is serious. At a time men like Jeffrey Sachs are celebrated as saviours of the world’s poor for example, in a Bono song dedication at last month’s big New York City concert – a deeper critique of markets and the NGOs which legitimate them is desperately needed.
Bono in particular has been obsequious. At the last New Labour party convention, Bono labeled Blair/Brown the ‘Lennon and McCartney of poverty reduction’. According to Quarmby, ‘some groups involved in Make Poverty History were horrified. John Hilary, director of campaigns and policy at War on Want, was in the audience. “When Bono said that, many NGO leaders who were there put their heads in their hands and groaned It’s a killer blow for us. To see the smiles on the faces of Gordon Brown and Tony Blair! This is exactly what they want – they want people to believe that this is their crusade, without actually changing their policy.”‘
Are the Make Poverty History campaign objectives for Gleneagles – greater Third World exposure to market mechanisms, a few crumbs of debt relief and a doubling of (neoliberally-conditioned) aid actually worth endorsing as a reformist step forward or should they be condemned as more of the same? In his book Deglobalization, Bello has convincingly set out the justice movement’s case for disempowering and defunding the global-scale institutions that push capitalism down Third World throats.
So when Sachs, Oxfam, Mbeki and others continue to insist that the way to cure poverty is to expand the world market and reverse Africa’s alleged ‘marginalization’, they elide the reality that Africa’s trade/GDP ratio has for many years topped the world charts, and the reality that ever-greater reliance upon exporting cash-crops and minerals most of which have suffered huge declines in price due to gluts is a recipe for underdevelopment.
When debt relief comes with more Western neoliberal conditionality, the reality is that people often end up in worse shape after relief than before.
And when G8 ‘phantom aid’ continues to foster Northern interests above those of the Third World’s people, it should be rethought entirely. In late May, Christian Aid’s brilliant Ghanaian researcher/campaigner Charles Abugre declared personally not organizationally – to a Globalise Resistance conference in London: ‘Stop the aid! It’s done too much damage!’