112177000757079466

Liberal islamophobia

analysed by “Lenin”:

Well, you’d either have to be living in a box, congenitally purblind or maintaining yourself in a state of wilful self-delusion not to spot it. Islamophobia is not in ‘competition’ with other forms of racism. It is contiguous with, indeed corroborates, other kinds of racism. Precisely the same strategies are deployed. At an official level, the language created to discuss these issues is clotted with such demeaning artefacts as ‘integration’, ‘citizenship’, ‘cohesion’ and ‘tolerance’. Instead of the focus being on social justice and human rights for all, it is shifted to a test for non-white immigrants: in order for me to tolerate you, the good liberal says, you will have to pass this citizenship test and integrate yourself properly into British society. And, often enough, precisely the same people who bang on about multiculturalism and Britain being a polyglot society will revert to this hand-wringing anxiety about ‘social cohesion’ being undermined by an influx of people whose values which are not sufficiently commensurable with those presently persisting in Britain – as if the values of Socialist Worker are compatible with those of Richard Branson.

At the level of casual racism, it is interesting to note just how much of this mandarin argot trickles down to ordinary discourse and commingles with the pub demotic. The more splenetic outbursts, whether in the media or on the street, replicate what was once said about black people and Jews: the insinuation of cultural backwardness, deviousness, hiding devils in their ranks, prone to criminality, getting lots of money off the state etc etc.

But the specificities of liberal Islamophobia are arresting as well. Polly Toynbee thinks that anything called the Islamic Human Rights Commission must be a contradiction in terms, and I am fairly certain I know why she thinks that. Toynbee can’t understand the distinction between Islam and Islamism. Johann Hari, in recent articles, can’t tell the difference between different kinds of Political Islam – although in his case, I’d make allowances for cluelessness. In other words, Islamophobes don’t just see Muslims as culturally backward, they see Islam and any movement it might spawn as necessarily politically retrograde and monolithic. And the tendency by some to celebrate and congratulate ‘secular’ or ‘apostate’ Muslims (like the silly sap, Irshad Manji) reminds me of nothing so much as the Christian fundamentalist dictum about homosexuals – love the sinner, hate the sin. We nice liberals love Muslims, and wish to draw them to our breasts if only they’ll recant. Anyone familiar with the Tomb will know I am an atheist and won’t be arguing for theocracy any time soon, but the way in which blatant racism has been sold under the guise of secularism – for instance, the French hijab ban, is enough to make me deeply sceptical of anyone who fetishises secularism, particularly when they do so especially for Muslims.