Nothing of interest happened — the Oblivious Saint — First Impressions

This first episode could’ve been a five minute prologue.

Grey haired, listless looking anime girl looks into the camera wishing she had one thing to be good at

Youngest daughter of a duke you say? Mother died in childbirth, elder sister is a genius and rumoured to be the kingdom’s next saint? The elder sister bullies the protagonist because she blames her for their mother’s dead? All of which has left the protagonist with no self confidence? And now there’s a crisis involving the much more powerful neighbouring empire and they need a bride for one of their princes? The one everybody thinks is a mad, blood thirsty killer with no heart? And our hero is the one chosen for this honor?

You really needed an entire episode to tell us all that?

Mujikaku Seijo wa Kyou mo Muishiki ni Chikara wo Tare Nagasu / The Oblivious Saint Can’t Contain Her Power is another entry in the fast growing saintess subgenre of narou slop, a slight revision of the villainess formula. That it took an entire episode to set up the situation in which the protagonist will inevitably discover she’s the real saint is not a good sign. That the opening and ending show a bevvy of bland looking handsome men also isn’t. Nothing of interest happened this episode, most of which was our poor Cinderella saintess-to-be thinking to herself. This could’ve been redeemed by interesting animation or character design but everything was done as straightforward as possible, so nothing sparked.

An easy drop.

Like Nobody is Watching — World Is Dancing — First Impressions

The rest of this first episode is done in that stolid, Serious Gritty Anime style also seen on e.g. Nippon Sangoku meaning the climx hits you as hard as it hit the protagonist:

What I expected from World is Dancing was something like Wandance, but instead I got a historical anime set during Japan’s Nanboku-cho period, when the country was in a civil war between the Northern and Southern Courts on who was backing the true emperor. Even in such grim times people still need entertainment and the Kanza troupe delivers. Kanami is the head of this group of sarugaku theatre performers. Oniyasha is his son, a bit of an airhead and dreamer and far from convinced dancing has the importance that his father ascribes to it.

Oniyasha sulking a bit, dressed in hsi theatre costume, with long black hair, purple eyes and thick, triangular eyebrows

Oniyasha has those thick, triangular eyebrows you usually see on cheerful, good hearted but slightly dim supporting characters. It fits him considering when we first meet him he’s so caught up in his own head he not only misses his cue to perform, he doesn’t even notice the horse about to trample him. Unlike his father, he seemingly has little talent for dance or theatre and often sneeks out of his lessons to go to a nearby river to play with his friend as they both complain about their respective families.

A group of weathered skulls, grass growing through them, cluttered together on a hill side

All very peaceful but the reminders of the recent wars are still everywhere. Most of this first episode is establishing first his world and how brutal it is, then Oniyasha himself, before his absent-mindedness makes him lost and a kindly farmer sends him in the direction of the faithful encounter he has in that clip above. There’s more to Oniyasha’s reluctance to take dancing seriously than how he’s treated by his father, who only has eyes for his art, or his own lack of talent in other words. At a time when even village festivals are cancelled because harvests are bad, why do people still dance? Nobody needs to dance, so why do people still do it every time they get the chance? This is an anime about art and I’m always a sucker for these. Making it a historical drama at the same time is the cherry on top.

This is a very good looking anime. As the clip above shows it’s not afraid to get all expressionistic when it needs to and even in its more staid moments, Oniyasha gets to make silly, comedic faces as he reacts to things. What I liked during that entire, climactic dance scene is how Oniyasha at times gets sucked in to the point of deforming into almost nothingness himself, then when he pulls back he’s depicted in that more realistic style again. The studio behind this, Cypic, is so new this is their first series and the director himself, Toshimasa Kuroyanagi doesn’t have many directorial roles to his credit, despite being in the industry for over twenty years. He did however direct one of my favourite anime of 2016, Fune wo Amu, which gives me some confidence in this production. If it can keep up the high production values it had this episode and the story remains interesting this will be a great series.

Unnecessarily Isekaied — All Works Maid — First Impressions

Average mahou shoujo fan during a transformation scene:

Extreme close up on a blue eyed, blonde haired anime girl saying

More seriously, All Works Maid (full title: Heroine? Seijo? Iie, All Works Maid desu (Hokori)!) is another in a long line of isekai series that didn’t need to be isekai.

Our protagonist is a girl with huge magical talent who’s obsessed with becoming a maid. When her mother dies, she set out to fulfil her dreams and ends up inservice to the young daughter of impoverished rural nobles, who have sent her on her own to the capital to study at the obligatory magic school. Our heroine is overjoyed to hear there’s no other staff and she has to be an “all works maid”, ie a maid who has to to all the jobs usually handled by different types of maid. She immediately transforms her clothes to her new maid uniform leading to the above remark by her new employer…

A small child holding up some sort of diploma, looking sad while the subtitles say she lost interest in the world, the whole thing being in black and white.

And then we get a lengthy flashback to her “real past” as a genius child in Tokyo who had lost all interest in things because everything was so easy for her. Until she first encountered a maid that is, which finally brought some colour in her monochrome world. Then reincarnated in this world she once again encountered a maid as a young child and recovered her old memories. Was this really necessary to make her a maid maniac when that encounter by itself would’ve sufficed? Or is this just an excuse to have her invent mayonnaise in a future episode?

For narouslop this was decent. A little bit of humour, a little bit of effort on the animation goes a long way to make a cliched setup like this more palatable. I suspect our heroine will join the magic school as well and of course she’s the illegitamite daughter of some important noble, so this will never be an original series, but could be a decent time waster if the rest of the season doesn’t pan out.

Be the change you want to see in the world

Jake Worth talks about making a friendlier, more humane internet

As a writer, receiving feedback on my work is welcome and rare. This blog gets thousands of readers a month, and yet the amount of direct feedback I’ve received over all the years is a small fraction of that.

I want to hear it! Praise is encouraging. Criticism is often enlightening. If it’s a nitpick or aside, that’s almost always interesting.

A pity then there isn’t a comment section on his blog. If you want people to reach out, make it as easy as possible for them to do so. I might’ve left a comment, but I sure as hell won’t hunt for a link to social media or gods forbid an email address to do the same.

via.

Nightwing: Leaping into the Light — Tom Taylor & Bruno Redondo — #Comicaday (74)

Dick Grayson does what internet critics always say Bruce Wayne should do and starts using his new found wealth to fix Blüdhaven.

Cover of Nightwing: Leaping into the Light showing Nightwing moving through an urban landscape

An underappreciated feature of DC’s Compact comics line is that, like manga, you can read them with one hand, leaving the other free to eat your supper. A more obvious advantage is that you get to sample new writers or artists for the low price of ten books. I bought this because I like Nightwing (I have always been a New Teen Titans fanboy). I hadn’t heard of either Tom Taylor or Bruno Redondo before.

Based on this though I’d like to see more of either. Taylor is a fun writer, able to give Nightwing a sense of humour without it becoming irritating while Redondo has a clean, well flowing art style that in his faces reminds me of Steve Lieber or Kevin Maguire. His fight scenes are assured too and I love the way he draws the city of Blüdhaven, seventies NYC by any other name. It has been a while since I’ve read such an assured, competent superhero story like this. Something that isn’t yet another event tie-in, nor trying to say something profound about what being a superhero is like.

No, this is just a collected slab of Nightwing continuity with all the pluses and minuses this brings with it. Nightwing: Leaping into the Light collects Nightwing 78-83 and 87-91, as well as Superman: Son of Kal-El 9, also written by Tom Taylor. This collect the start of Taylor and Redondo’s run on Nightwing, on which they stayed until issue 118, a rather respectable run for any creative team these days.

You’ll notice that there’s a three issue gap in the middle of the collection, so it’s not quite a straight forward chronological run. Nor is the plot line in the crossover with Superman: Son of Kal-El resolved; you have to buy that series’ collections if you want to know what happened next. Finally, much as it was easy to get into it, this isn’t quite a clean start: things happened to Nightwing recently that are still refered to, but you really don’t need to know more about them then what Taylor already tells you about them…

Calvin asks why superheroes do not fight more realistic threats, to which Hobbes responds that would be boring. 'Quick, to the batfax!'

What Taylor and Redondo do with Nightwing is basically taking this old Calvimn & Hobbes gag seriously: what if Bruce Wayne/Batman stopped beating up costumed weirdos and put his vast wealth to work making Gotham City better? They do this by making Dick Grayson a billionaire in their very first issue by having him be the heir to Alfred “Batman’s butler” Pennyworth’s wealth. (He also adopts a dog: Haley, aka Bitewing). Having done some soul searching and having come into contact with Blüdhaven;s large unhoused population he decide that this is where he’ll focus his efforts first. When asked why this particular issue, he answers that it will get colder soon.

If based on this you’re expecting a semi-realistic comic about the difficulties setting up a charitable foundation or the like you’ll be disappointed however. Dick Grayson’s plans infuriate the criminal rulers of Blüdhaven and they immediately put a price on his head, the resolution of which is the main plot in this volume, as a series of increasingly dangerous assassins come after him. What I liked about this is that Nightwing doesn’t faces these dangers on his own. Both his team mates in the Titans as well as members of the extended Bat family come over to help him, most noticably one Barbara “Batgirl/Oracle” Gordon, with whom Dick rekindles his long running off and on relationship. I like that sense of a wider world and superhero community, it reminds me of the Bronze Age superhero series I grew up with.