Yes, there was an anime backlash in the nineties

The latest controversy in Anisky was caused by this perfectly true Zero Utopia tweet which a lot of people took umbrage with for some reason:

Genuinely impossible to make people understand how much most the United States in the 90s hated and looked down on anime if they didn’t live through it.

A common reaction was yo say this couldn’t be true because anime became popular in the nineties, like Zack Davisson here

This is bullshit.

Dragonball, Sailor Moon, and Pokemon were ridiculously popular in the 90s.

There was never a time in the US when people “hated and looked down on anime.” At the most, there was a time when people were “unaware of anime.”

The other common response was to downplay it as just bullies being bullies as James Beckett e.g. argued


The U.S. didn’t “hate” anime in the 90s. People these days tend to conflate (or confuse) “broad teasing of foreign cultures and nerd hobbies” for “hatred.”

As for the nerds and bullies that may have gotten weird or douchey about it…I mean, what do you expect? That’s what nerds and bullies do.

What this misses is that bullies (as well as South Park mentioned later) take their cues from the larger culture they’re swimming in. And Japan was the number one target of American xenophobia for most of the twentieth century. The anime backlash of the nineties, when anime first truly went mainstream with Pokemon was very real and very much an offshoot of that much older xenophobia. Just like the slightly later backlash in the early 2000s against Japanese videogames, especially JRPGGs (the X-Box first being called “project Midway” frex).

Japan after all was America’s primary rival for supremacy in the Pacific and East Asia from roughly 1905 until its defeat in World War II. Japan was feared and mistrusted not just for its military strength and rapid climb from insular hermit state incapable of defending itself into a Great Power threatening the US’s position in China and elsewhere. A far greater fear was that Japan would infiltrate and subvert the country itself, by way of the many Japanese migrants who moved to the US in the late nineteenth and twentieth century. A fear so powerful even the great liberal president Roosevelt ended up putting American citizens in concentration camps for the duration of the war. (For a victim’s testimony of this awful proces, see Citizen 13660, a graphic novel written by a survivor in 1946).

Agents of Influence: How Japan Manipulates America's Politicl and Economic System (1990) by Pat Choate. The cover shows an American flag with the rising sun replacing the stars ibn the corner.

Postwar, Japan subjugated and occupied this fear slowly disappeared, but the xenophobic attitude didn’t disappear. World War II and especially Pearl Harbour gave new reasons to mistrust Japan and a lot of americans would hold that grudge into the twentyfirst century. Meanwhile Japan’s economic resurgence from the sixties and America’s industrial decline from the early seventies on saw this xenophobia re-ignite again. Once again Japan was seen as infiltrating and taking over America, now using economic warfare.

By the eighties American economic anxiety was so great you got Chrysler CEO Lee Iacocca talking about Japan’s “teflon kimono” that needed taking off and books like this happily resurrecting pre-WWII infiltration conspiracies. Japan’s econmic stagnation since the mid-nineties has driven much of it underground again, with China replacing Japan as the new bogeyman, but it was still very much present in the nineties when anime broke through, slotting perfectly in with the preconcieved notions of Japan as weird and dangerous.

Zack is right that series like Dragonball and Pokemon were incredibly popular, but they were popular among kids (and maybe but not necessairly the older cohort of already existing anime fans). As Elvis Presley proved some fory years earlier, what’s popular with kids and teens may very well lead to a backlash under their parents and authority figures. So it went with anime too. Parents hated Pokemon, certain churches declared it “satanic” (like everything they didn’t understand) and even in nerd circles anime was tolerated at best. True acceptance of anime only happened this century.

It’s a Yuri Anime Summer!

Nine series and one movie with yuri elements is enough to make anybody’s head spin. Right, Major?

The Major's head is spinning after her girlfriends teased her a bit too much

To be honest, nine out of sixtynine (nice) new series this season is not even fifteen percent yuri this season and not all series listed here will have actual yuri romance, but after years and years of maybe getting one or two Manga Time Kirara a year, I take what I can get. Series listed below are in under of their start date.

Heroine? Seijo? Iie, All Works Maid desu (Hokori)!
A genius girl reincarnates into the world of an otome game and instead of trying to be the hero or saintess, decides she’d rather skip all that and be a maid, like she dreamed of in her previous life. The opening and ending give away the likely heterosexual end game, but that doesn’t erase the romantic tension between her and her mistress.

Grow Up Show: Himawari no Circus-dan
Mizuka is the daughter of the world’s greatest trapeze artist. Unfortunately she hates both the circus and her father, especially after he ‘sells’ her to the Sunflower Circus, a dilapidated all-girls troupe. Nevertheless, years of dedicated training having giving her trapeze skills that make Ouka, the circus’ existing trapeze artist, immediately obsessed with her. So far this feels like an ensemble cast show focusing on the circus and its performers more than any possible romance between Mizuka and Ouka. But we can hope.

Viola' Yumenita's villain, looking particularly evil in close-up

BanG Dream! Yume∞Mita
After MyGo and Ave Mujica you might’ve thought Bang Dream would’ve run out of blorpos to torture, but nope, here’s a brand new batch and now they’re vtubers, thrown together to become a band. The main protagonist, Arale, has a Dark Past that left her traumatised and a childhood friend in a rival band who shared that past. Worse, that childhood friends shares the band with the main cause of Arale’s trauma, the very evil indeed for Bandori standards Viola. It all makes for a deliciously toxic if chaste yuri love triangle.

Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha EXCEEDS: Gun Blaze Vengeance
With the possible exception of Hibki & Miku, Nonoha and Fate are the reigning yuri couple of mahou shoujo series, having gone so far as to adopt a daughter together in a previous one. This may be set before that happened, but also opens with a loving pair of “sisters” living together before Nanoha even enters the picture.

Sayonara Lara
Episode one was a straight (no pun intended) retelling of the story of the Little Mermaid but ended with a meet cute between the two protagonists as Laura the mermaid fell out of the sky onto Mari the boixer, who immediately punched her lights out. And then she took Laura home to meet her family. Given that Laura was sent into the human world to search for true love by her evil (?) withc aunt to save her family from her own curse, odds are high that Mari might be just that.

In a recent interview the director said he didn’t want to make it “a ‘typical’ yuri anime” and that he wanted to “portray their relationship with strength and complexity. Depending on your cynicism this is either a good or a bad sign. Does not wanting to be a “typical” yuri anime mean that ti’ll be all about female friendship rather than proper romance, as more pessimistic fans think? Or will director Koide Takushi surprised us and deliver a strong, complex romance?

Honoo no Toukyuujo: Dodge Danko
A bunch of dumbass girls start a dodgeball club together. Based on the sequel to a nineties dodgeball manga, whose protagonist is this series’ protagonist’s dead father. The focus here is on dodgeball and the various antics the club members get up to, with any yuri being on the fanservice side of things. It’s all very much too what you might suspect from a modern sequel to a nineties series, not very subtle in its humour or fanservice.

The Ghost in the Shell
Such a faithful adaptation of Shirow Masamune;s original manga that it reinstituted the lesbian threesome scene in its fsecond episode that was removed with Shirow’s blessing from the manga reprints ever since the first publication. The Major was always portrayed as bisexual but it never actually mattered in previous Ghost in the Shell projects. Don’t expect much more lesbianism in future episodes either, to be honest. But at least she has proper emotions in this series!

Two girls swapppign magical energy. With tongue.

Kimi ga Shinu made Koi wo Shitai
Sheena is the weakest pupil at the school for magical assassins the government put her in when she became orphaned. The night after her roommate died in battle, she couldn’t sleep and went for a walk only to meet a blood soaked girl she’d never seen before. Because she feeds the girl onigir, Mimi becomes obsessed with her to the point of becoming her new roommate and joining her class. Will this be the start of a truly toxic romance? The title, I Want to Love You Till Your Dying Day certainly promises as much. Encouraging is that while there are boys at the school, they have been non-entities and there’s actually at least one other yuri couple there. Also, by kissing somebody who is on the same wavelength as you, you can restore their health. Uh-huh.

Tai-Ari deshita. Ojousama wa Kakutou Game nante Shinai
Ojo-samas flirt by playing Street Fighter at each other. Aya used to play fighting games as a child until all her friends grew out of it. Despite her talents, she decided to quit to and join Kuromi Girls Academy to become a proper lady. Mio, also known as Shirayuki, “the white lily” already is that, the idol of all the other girls at school. And then Ayo catches Mio playing Street Fighter online in an unused classroom, something highly forbidden at Kuromi Academy… By the end of the first episode they’ve not only fought each other so hard their lips are bleeding from biting them, but they crashed through a plate glass window to escape when a custodian threatend to discover them…

I have high hopes.

Shibou Yuugi de Meshi wo Kuu. 44: Cloudy Beach
Young girls being made to fight their environment and each other in sadistic death games broadcast to an audience of perverts unable to stand the sight of blood, so it’s all transmuted into cotton, as if they’re just dolls being broken. The participants, desperate and badly adjusted to the real world, finding some sense of comfort in each other, even forming emotional ties with their female handlers responsible for sending them into these situations in the first place. Is there a more perfect platonic form of toxic yuri possible? This is a movie sequel to last season’s original series, promising more of the same twisted thrills.

Now with Definitive Article — The Ghost in the Shell — First Impressions

This may be the more faithful adaptation of Shirow’s manga but I can’t get over how much Aramaki looks like he escaped from The simpsons.

Aramaki in profile gesturing looking like he just came out of a meeting with Homer Simpson

My first encounter with any Ghost in the Shell media came through Wandue Project’s King of my Castle, which hit the top forty over here in 1998 or so, thanks to its music video basically being a Ghost in the Shell AMV. No idea how they got away with it, not just the wholesale copyright infringement but also showing the Major’s boobies on MTV. The 1995 movie the clip was taken from I would only see years later, having stopped watching anime when I left home to go study in Amsterdam. Whem I got back in anime both it and both seasons of Stand Alone Complex were some of the earliest anime I finished. I’ve also watched the second movie and Arise, the mid (in both sense of the word) 2010s re-imagination. This new version is nothing like those even as familiar bits and pieces pop up.

The Major, with green hair and a wide face, looking angry and blushing.

Because unlike every other incarnation of Ghost in the Shell this new version, The Ghost in the Shell attempts to stay faithful to Masamune Shirow’s original manga. which includes character designs, which explains why the Major above here has green hair and is actually blushing and showing emotion, while Aramaki really looks like a monkey now. In contrast every other version cleaned up the characters and made them more realistic. Similar for the plot and stories. Having bought the manga on the strength of this episode, I can see the way Mamoru Oshii took parts of it and sculpted them into one new, coherent story where the original was more episodical.

Having this new, more faithful adaptation is very much a “holy shit two cakes” situation. The original movies, Stand Alone Complex, even Arise were all good to great on their own merits. This new series is not just faithful but also looks stunning and so far holds up to its predecessors. Very much in my top five for this season, potentially the entire year. Sasuga Science Saru.

Disney would never — Sayonara Lara — First Impressions

We first meet Lara when she’s born from her clamshell:

If you know Hans Christian Anders’ The Little Mermaid you know roughly how this first episode goes. Lara grows up, gets curious about humans and the human world, rescues a prince falling overboard from a burning ship, gets seduced by her witch aunt to become human herself, it all ends in tragedy and she dies. Centuries later she returns to life to find her old home abandoned, her family dead or on the brink of death. Now her aunt challenges her to rescue them, by giving Lara a trial and Lara finds herself falling out of the sky over modern day Japan, on her way to the meet cute with the series other protagonist…

And that’s where the episode ends. Not quite a Disney ending.

This is Kinema Citrus’ big fifteenth anniversary project and you can see the care and attention lavished on it. The animation and character design are both gorgous. The characters have actual noses, a rarity in modern anime, with less rounded faces than we’ve gotten used to as well. It’s an older sort of character styling without being retro, unlike e.g. Iron Wok Jan this season, which wears its nineties aesthetic on its sleeves. What I also liked was the care and invention shown in depicting mermaid society and the use of colour therein.

With this first episode being the ‘origin story’ so to speak, it’s hard to say what the rest of the series will be like, but it looks like its central message will be a refutation of The Little Mermaid, that a mermaid could love a human and not suffer for it. In a season already packed with excellent anime, this still stands out.

Gap Moe — Saijo no Osewa — First Impressions

Mum, can we get Hayate the Combat Butler? No, we got Hayate the Combat Butler at home. Hayate the Combat Butler at home:

An anime girl tied up in chains saying she gonna pee herself to an also tied up anime boy

Yes, Saijo no Osewa (full title: Saijo no Osewa: Takane no Hanadarake na Meimonkou de, Gakuin Ichi no Ojousama (Seikatsu Nouryoku Kaimu) wo Kagenagara Osewa suru Koto ni Narimashita) is very much cribbing from Hayate. It got a hapless, unlucky poor protagonist having to work half a dozen part time jobs to cover his school tuition because his parents are useless, with said parents immediately running off with his money at the start of this first episode. Luckily for Itsuki, unlike Hayate, they didn’t sell him to a bunch of nice guys, but he’s still left with only 200 yen to his name and the rent due. And then he gets involved in the kidnap of the rich girl seen above, she takes a liking to him and he’s hired as her caretaker.

An anime girl, lying as a blob on the ground in a changing room as another anime girl pleads with her to get changed

Konohana Hinako is one of those hyper competent ojo-samas anime is so fond of. Good lucking, excellent student, great at sports, heir to a huge conglomerate. But in private she’s a lazy, selfish slob that has driven all her previous caretakers to madness. And now it’s Itsuki’s job to take care of her, as she has taken a real like to him. Which means enrolling into her rich people school. Unlike Hayate Itsuki doesn’t have a millions of yen debt hanging over his head and even gets paid for his new job. In typical idiotic too nice for his own good protagonist fashion he at first refuses the offering pay of 20,000 yen a day (or roughly $200) thinking it far too much when in reality this seems on the low side for such a demanding job…

Having read the manga version of this, I roughly knew what to expect going in. the appeal of this series is of course the wishfulfilment fantasy of being the competent hero who is the only one the heroine can show her useless, vulnerable side to. There will of course be other girls later on to complicate things for Itsuki. Whether or not I’ll keep watching depends on the execution: this first episode was okay, but not great. Character designs are a bit meh, the animation itself is average but it does have some bright touches, mostly with Hinako’s transformations into her useless moeblob form. A series to turn your brain of for.