Now I know how the Germans felt all those years

Giovanni van Bronckhorst scores in the semis

For the longest part in the Worldcup Holland was barely noticed. The world press talked about how badly England and France and Italy did and how Germany had a good youthfull team but which was not quite up to winning the title and how it was going to be Brazil or Spain finally or perhaps even Argentine for the win. Even after winning every game in the group phase, after winning the next match against Slovakia not much attention was paid — Brazil would puliverse the Dutch was the general opinion. It was only after Brazil was beaten like a redheaded stepchild that the press sat up and took notice.

Suddenly I know how the Germans felt through all those tournaments when they were cruising towards yet another title and everybody condemned them for not playing proper football. Because suddenly Holland as well is accused of not playing our usual beautiful football and only winning by making it impossible for others to play, by diving and cheating. The comments on this
Guardian thread are typical.

It’s gratifying. Let them moan, as long as Oranje wins I’m not bothered.

UPDATE: we’re in the finals. So long suckers.

Hard cases make bad law even in football

Suarez proves he's a worldclass keeper

Suarez’s Hand of God lite has once again put the refereing and rules of football in the spotlight. This time the referee made the correct decision to send off Suarez for his handball but was it Asamoah Gyan who twatted the penalty, which meant Ghana didn’t win the regular game but lost in penalties. Our sense of fair play is outraged by this, that somebody can blatantly cheat and get punished for it yet still get his team in the semi-finals. Together with several other high profile incidents like England’s disallowed equaliser against Germany which sent them out of the Worldcup there’s been somewhat of a clamour for changes in the rules, you may have noticed.

First there was the call on FIFA to finally introduce proper goal line technology and television replays, after that disallowed England goal and an Argentine goal against Mexico that was blatantly offside but not spotted by the refs, both on the same day. In both cases the goals were turning points in the game and if not for the decision they could’ve taken a different turn. Had there been goalline detectors to show the ball had crossed the line in the first case, or had video replays been officially available to the refs in the second, these injustices would’ve been prevented.

With Suarez, the outrage is focused not on the decision, but on the sanctions. Somehow after Uruguay went on to win their game on penalties, having Suarez sent off and a penalty awarded just did not seem enough. Various pundits, fans and interested bystanders instead would’ve liked to have seen not a penalty, but a goal awarded in situations like this. That way we would be certain cheaters aren’t rewarded.

These calls are understandable, but misguided. Lawyers have a saying: hard cases make bad law and that goes for football as well. Handballs are a dime a dozen, but situations like we saw in Uruguay-Ghana game are incredibly rare. In more normal situations, where a handball might have prevented a goal but the game is far from over anyway, to punish a team with a goal and a sending off is too harsh — a penalty will suffice and is usually succesful anyway. Guaranteed goals also go against the spirit of football in which only actually scored goals count and which doesn’t deal with goals that should have been scored. That’s part of the charm and frustration of football.

The need for more technology I sort of share, but I can also understand why people other than Sepp Blatter disagree with that. Again, the two examples above are so rare and so blatant it’s not that likely they will be repeated often. In fact, technology wasn’t actually needed in either of them, just referees which weren’t halfblind and looking the other way.. For more ordinary, less obvious situations the question is how to integrate this sort of technology in the flow of the game. It’s easy to use video playback to retroactively disallow a goal, but if a referee has disallowed a goal and the game goes on, how do you go from there? Would we really want to make football into a more static game, ala rugby or American football, where coaches can challenge decisions on the field?

Metal Monday – reports of my death

O is for Obituary, another Florida based Death Metal band, who first got together in the eighties — and really what else there was to do in Tampa Florida in the eighties? They played around for a couple of years before releasing their debut in ’89, but what a debut. Slowly We Rot was a masterpiece, one of those records you have to play loud on headphones to get the sound reverbing round your skull and the bass guitar echoing on your ear drums for days after. The title song especially was great, starting off slow and doom laden and then the song speeds up for the vocals and the hall erupts. I dare anybody not to start moshing to it:



From their second album Cause of Death comes “Find the Arise”, another personal favourite:



Only found two good videos this week I’m afraid; more next week.

Books read June

Only five books this month — blame the football in the second half of the month, the hot weather and having to take care of my girlfriend coming back from hospital.

As Used on the Famous Nelson Mandela — Mark Thomas
Comedian Mark Thomas looks at the international arms trade.

The Origins of the British — Stephen Oppenheimer
An exhaustive look at the genetic evidence for where the British came from and when they arrived. Surprise, it’s not quite what’s being taught in school…

Fleshmarket Close — Ian Rankin
Sometimes you need a properly depressing police procedural to get you through the day. Rankin’s Rebus stories are always good for that.

Firewall — Henning Mankell
But for a real dose of existentialistic angst with your detective story, go to Henning Mankell.

The Reconstruction of Nations — Timothy Snyder
An interesting if difficult in places case study of the interaction between history, memory and the modern idea of the nation, looking at how Poland, Lithuania, Belarus and the Ukraine evolved from a early modern state based around elite consensus into four separate ethnically basded states build on support from the masses.

Did Luis Suarez cheat?

Yes, yes he did. But hang on, Dave Brockington disagrees:

No. He did the rational thing. It was perhaps not the sporting, moral, or ethical choice, and definitely the cynical choice, but given the nature of the match, he made the correct decision.

If he doesn’t act, the ball goes in, and Uruguay are out. Plain and simple. If he acts, there’s a small chance that he does not get spotted by the referee (again, see USA v Germany 2002). If he does get spotted and correctly sent off, there’s a chance that Ghana miss the penalty. The odds of both of those events occurring in that order are slim, but as luck would have it, did indeed occur. Suarez didn’t cheat, he operated within the rules of the game. Odds are Ghana would have converted the penalty, and we wouldn’t be discussing this. However, they didn’t, and continued to miss a couple more during the shootout.

In the ensuing 100+ comment thread a lot of people agree with Dave, making the comparison with basketball, where apparantly it’s accepted practise when you’re losing to start fouling a few minutes from time to break your opponent’s streak. You make the foul, you take the punishment if caught, it’s all in the rules and you’re not a cheater.

It’s the same sort of logic used by speeders everywhere. A co-worker of mine just the other day explained he was more than happy to pay the occasional fine for the priviledge of being home sooner, all part of the system and no great crime. The same again goes for tax cheats, who’d argue that fiddling the tax man is the rational thing to do and if you’re caught, pay the fines and fiddle again next year. And of course it turned out the entire financial system was populated by people who thought that the rules did not apply to them…

This sort of supposedly rational tradeoffs — where punishment is seen purely as the potential cost of a transaction rather than as a sanction — hollows out systems. If actions like Suarez’s last night are seen as understandable, even laudable or the right thing to do in the circumstances, this means more people will attempt it, rather than playing within the spirit of the game. Doing the convenient thing rather than the right thing might be endemic in basketball, but I don’t want to see it happen in football — or at least not more than it already has. What Suarez did was cheating, he didn’t make a rational tradeoff but got punished for breaking the rules and hopefully Holland will kick Uruguay out of the tournament next Tuesday…