“failing to provide for the health, safety and welfare of Jean Charles de Menezes”

Jean Charles de Menezes, murdered

That is the charge against the Metropolitian Police in the trail for their murder of Jean Charles de Menezes two years ago: “failing to provide for the health, safety and welfare of Jean Charles de Menezes”. No individual police officers have been charged, just the Met as a whole. It’s not verys atisfying isn’t it, that the police can gun down an innocent man in the middle of London with the worst that they can expect for it some slap on the wrist for violating health and safety laws!

If you want to follow the trial, the Guardian has a good set of reports available, something they’re reasonably good at. Myself, I’m not sure I will bother, as the usual excuses are trotted out once again for the inexcusable:

“I have, since that time, constantly thought about what other potential tactics or strategy might have been available to me because of the outcome of this tragic set of circumstances,” Mr McDowell told the jury.

“I have done that on a weekly, if not daily, basis. “I remain of the view that I and we did our best that morning to mitigate what was clearly a threat to the public in very difficult circumstances.”

It’s the talk of a “clear threat” that gets me everytime. Because if there’s one thing that is clear, it’s that there wasn’t a threat. Jean Charles de Menezes was just a guy going off to work, not a terrorist, not involved in anything even remotely associated with terrorism and he was shot down in cold blood. If it could happen to him it can happen to anybody, and the policy under which he was shot is still in effect…

Happy birthday Sputnik

Sputnik 1

fifty years ago today the first manmade object reached orbit. Science fiction fans everywhere thought it would be the start of mankind’s thriumphant conquest of space, even if it was the Russkies who did it, but it didn’t quite work out that way. While we’re using satellites for all kinds of important stuff, that whole idea that humanity had to leave its cradle behind seemed a lot less attractive in reality than science fiction had made it seem — quite a lot harder as well. We’re struggling to get a space station capable of keeping half a dozen astronauts living there for a month or two up and running, let alone that we can get the million inhabitants L5 colonies O’Neill dreams up going. For now, the future seems to be Earth orbit satellites and unmanned probes to the rest of the Solar System, plus the occasional hype of a new Moon or Mars programme

Should we be disappointed with this? That we have no giant space colonies, no Moonbase, no exploration of Mars, no interstellar expeditions? Or should we be happy instead with the things we do have: a Solar System far more interesting and odd than anybody had ever imagined, Earthbound telescopes powerful enough to detect planets around other stars, extrasolar planets where nobody would’ve believed planets could exist, an universe fastly more wonderful than any science fiction writer ever imagined?

Me, I’d rather go for wonder than for disappointment; I just wish much of science fiction would do the same and embrace the universe we live in rather than the universe we wished we lived in. Too much modern science fiction wallows in nostalgia or tries to refit the real universe into the old cliches.

Iran, Israel and the Bomb

Avedon Carol quotes Israeli historian Martin van Creveld on Iran and nuclear weapons: “Since 1945 hardly one year has gone by in which some voices — mainly American ones concerned about preserving Washington’s monopoly over nuclear weapons to the greatest extent possible — did not decry the terrible consequences that would follow if additional countries went nuclear. So far, not one of those warnings has come true. To the contrary: in every place where nuclear weapons were introduced, large-scale wars between their owners have disappeared.”

Carefully not noted by Martin is a) the lack of evidence about Iran’s alleged attempts to create nuclear weapons and b) the fact that there is one country in the Middle East which unquestionably does have nuclear weapons which it has never admitted to: Israel…

Good liberal wars

In the middle of a good review of two rightwing revisionist books about the War on Vietnam, Rick Perlstein says something profound but obvious:

And yet, in his own confused way, Moyar is also onto something. Americans, even “neoconservative” ones, are prone to liberal sentimentalizing about the possibility of “good” wars. But war is not good. War is the attempt of one group to violently impose its will on another. Fields of blood and fire are no kind of workshop for Jeffersonian democracy.

Yet nonetheless quite a few people who would say of themselves that they are of the left, and I’m not just talking about Decentists, have this illusion that it is possible to wage war for democracy, or human rights. Hence Kosovo, Afghanistan and, to a certain extent, Iraq. In all cases war supporting leftists were not the ones who made these wars possible, but helped legitimise them by providing non-official (and non-binding!) motivations for supporting them.

Kettle chips: not as wholesome as you think

It’s an old story. A supposedly wholesome company which takes good care of its workers and which takes pride in presenting a benign image to its customers, is less than happy when its workers want to unionise. This time it’s the people behind Kettle chips who object:

It says it has had to seek advice from “a number of sources” to fight what it considers are union experts in organising recognition campaigns. It did not comment directly on employing Omega Training, part of the Burke Group. The company does not want to recognise a union. It said: “We are very proud of our workforce and continue to believe passionately that direct engagement with employees in the spirit of mutuality is in the best interests of our employees and shareholders.”

A spokesman added: “All our employees enjoy a secure salary (the lowest of which is 25% above the minimum wage); we have a 38-hour week with 25 days’ paid holiday per annum increasing with service, and we offer a blue-chip benefits package that includes 100% sick pay … and a profit-sharing bonus that is open to all employees. We’re not sure what Unite the union wish to do for our employees.”

The union is baffled why the company is so determined to block recognition. Miles Hubbard, Unite’s eastern region organiser, said: “They are a good company with a decent record so we cannot understand why they are being so aggressive about union activity. We were called in by the workers when they did not receive annualised payments for overtime.”

What both sides in this dispute talk around is the simple fact that with an union, the workers at Kettle chips no longer have to depend on the company’s goodwill to be treated right, but have a powerful weapon to force management to do the right thing. At the moment, “direct engagement with employees in the spirit of mutuality” may be “in the best interests of our employees and shareholders”, but what if the interest of employees and shareholders clash? Without an union, the workers at Kettle chips would be at the mercy of the company. Unions are like insurance: you may not need them now, but it pays to have it for when you do need it.

If Kettle chips or its parent company were really as benign as they say they are, they would not be threatened by this unionising attempt. But like many a patriarchal company before them(Remember Whole Foods?), they want to be generous to their employees on their terms, on bended knees and dependent on the company.

Hattip: Avedon