That’s the latest meme in the “deny the undenyable” sweepstakes, the attempts to wish away the Lancet report. I first came across it yesterday, in the comments to this post over at Charlie’s, when Charlie brought up the simple fact that because the occupiers refuse to keep records, the Lancet studies are the best estimates we have of Iraqi deaths. Several people responded to this with variations on ‘the “occupation” ended a couple of years ago’, as if the tens of thousands of foreign troops waging war on the Iraqi population is somehow magicked away by some sort of meaningless handover ceremony. Clue: the US and UK forces are not under Iraqi command.
You have to wonder about the mindset of people who are able to ignore 600,000 deaths by arguing that well, the Coalition wasn’t in control so that makes it all right…
First things first: the report is now online (PDF file). I still need to read it properly, but in the meantime I’d like to talk about the likely media reaction to the report. Already in the LA Times article I linked to below you could see the narrative about the report taking shape, which was confirmed for me by the BBC news report on it during PM.
What is stressed in both cases is 1) how controversial the previous Lancet report was, 2) how out of line the new report is with other and/or official counts (with specific emphasis on Bush’s own estimate of 30,000 deaths earlier this year and the Iraqi Bodycount Project) and 3) the official rejections of the report. What is not reported is that the scientific accuracy of the previous report was never in question, other than by political hacks (See Tim Lambert’s sterling debunking work for more details), nor is explained how the differences in methology between the Lancet report and the Iraqi Bodycount Project makes them incomparable. The latter after all only counts deaths reported in western media and hence misses the vast majority of Iraqi deaths.
This approach is not that surprising: it’s safe ‘n easy, lazy journalism, biased towards the status quo. While Americans may think the BBC is largely immune to the inane habit of “balanced reporting” where the opinion of both sides in an argument is given equal weight, no matter where the truth lies their own newsmedia is infected with, reports like this sadly show this is not the case. Even the BBC is biased towards the status quo and not much interested in investigating the truth. There’s no calculated malice behind this, just the everyday pressures of being a news organisation, one of which is getting the news out now rather than after careful investigation. Later perhaps the claims of both parties can be examined for truth, but by then the newscycle might have already moved on and in any case the false claims are well established.
(This Lenin’s Tomb post has more evidence of the increassing laziness of the BBC’s news teams, in their answer as to why they didn’t pay any attention to the BNP terrorism case.)
This according to a new study to be published in The Lancet this week, by the same team who did the much maligned 2004 study also published there, which was the first scientific study to the effects of the War on Iraq. The news this time is much worse:
WASHINGTON — More than 600,000 Iraqis have died violently since the U.S.-led invasion, according to a new estimate that is far higher than any other to date.
The report, by a team of researchers criticized for its death estimates two years ago, says that 601,027 Iraqis have suffered violent deaths since the March 2003 invasion. It also suggests that the country has become more violent in the last year.
“This clearly is a much higher number than many people have been thinking about,” said Gilbert Burnham, the report’s lead author and a professor at the Bloomberg School of Public Health at Johns Hopkins University. “It shows the violence has spread across the country.”
Iraq’s violent death rate rose from 3.2 deaths per 1,000 people in the year after the invasion to 12 per 1,000 from June 2005 to June 2006, according to the researchers, whose findings are being published this week in the British medical journal Lancet.
The article tries its best to throw mud on the study, dragging in all kinds of irrelevancies like the Iraqi Bodycount Project, all of which is still familiar from the 2004 study and all of which fails to conceal the magnitude of this disaster. It’s so much more than expected that I don’t know what to say about it, only to note that none of this was necessary.
Have you heard about the terrorism case coming before Burnley Crown Court later this month? No? That might be because there were no big raids, no special press conferences by the Home Secretary, no well-timed police leaks and yet not only where various chemical components found at the two subjects’ houses (the largest ever haul from a private home ever, according to the police) but also a rocket launcher and an NBC suit! So why does Google News only find eight articles about this?
Might it be because the subjects here were not Muslims, but white (ex-)British National Party members? The story does not fit in the government’s and media’s narrative about terrorism, so it’s ignored.
It’s seventy years ago that the Battle of Cable Street against Mosley’s fascists was fought and won by a broad coalition of Jews, trade unionists, Labour Party members, Communists and residents. It showed that anti-fascists forces could win these battles, despite police interference, despite unwillingness on the part of the then Communist Party leadership to commit themselves to the battle. Ordinary people could defeat fascists as long as they were united against it. Even though, as this this eyewitness report shows, the police was largely on the fascists side and was busy protecting their march.
That’s the other lesson of Cable Street of course, that the police is far more willing to use violence to protect fascist’ demonstrations against leftwingers than it is to do the opposite. You still see this whenever the modern equivalent of Mosley’s fascists march like recently in Amsterdam, when under the guise of an anti-pedophile march skinheads marched through Amsterdam-zuid, a neighbourhood with a large Jewish presence…
Of course you can have some sympathy for the view that in a democracy any group, no matter how odious their views, should be allowed to air them, as long as they stay within the law while doing so. But even when they don’t stay within the law, the police has a remarkable reluctance to take the fascists on, as the case of Redwatch shows:
Alec McFadden was dozing in his armchair when a loud bang on his front door brought him to his senses with a jolt. Looking out of the window of his Wallasey home, he saw a young man half slumped in the driveway. “I couldn’t see his face but he looked like he was in some sort of trouble, like he needed help,” says McFadden. “I opened the door just a bit to ask if he was OK and he threw himself at me and started hitting me around the head.”
What McFadden did not realise at the time was that he was not being punched but stabbed. “I think it went on for a couple of minutes before I managed to get the door closed. I turned round and my daughter was screaming. It was only then, as I put my hand to my face and felt the blood, that I realised what had happened.”
The attack, which left the long-time union activist with serious injuries, was the latest and most violent incident in a campaign of intimidation that has been waged against opponents of the far right in the UK over the past five years. Like hundreds of people who have spoken out against the rise of the British National Party and other extremist groups, McFadden’s picture and home address have been collected by far right activists and posted on a website called Redwatch.
The site, which has links with the neo-Nazi organisation Combat 18 and a host of European fascist organisations, is hosted in the US but registered and run from the UK. It lists the personal details and shows the photographs of anti-racists – many taken during protests against the British National Party – alongside the slogan: “Remember places, traitors’ faces, they’ll all pay for their crimes.” This month a delegation of MPs and union activists will visit the Home Office to call for the site to be closed down. It is a familiar refrain and in the past officials have argued that because the site is hosted abroad, there is nothing they can do. However, Redwatch’s sister site in Poland, which was also hosted in the US, was recently closed down after collaboration between authorities in the the two countries, and Home Office minister Vernon Coaker has agreed to champion the campaign within government.
So seventy years after the police attempted to let Mosley march through the Jewish area of Cable Street, the Home Office protects the right of Mosley’s spiritual heirs to intimidate and attack leftwingers and antifascists.