Letter to the Observer

Sir,

it takes particular cheek to cite the partisan TCS website refering to the Lancet as “Al-Jazeera on the Thames” when the website in question is well known for its activism on behalf of corporate intrerests and the “journalist” who provided you with this quote has managed to both misread and misrepresent the Lancet report [1] in his own writings on the subject.

He made exactly the same mistake as your article did when it stated that:

The report’s authors admit it drew heavily on the rebel stronghold of Falluja, which has been plagued by fierce fighting. Strip out Falluja, as the study itself acknowledged, and the mortality rate is reduced dramatically.

When in fact the excess mortality figure the report arrived at, of 98,000, was reached with the Falluja figures left out of the calculations. If these had been included, the figure would have been even higher.

All of which leads me to conclude that the writer of your article, rather than reading the report itself and drawing his own conclusions, has instead relied on the accusations of those for whom this report is embarassing and who have an ulterior motive in bringing it into doubt.

Yours sincerily,

Martin Wisse

[1]: PDF file

The killing of Theo van Gogh

It may just be for the best that Dutch filmaker and writer Theo van Gogh was killed on the day of the US elections, as that way we may possibly be spared the mock outrage and parading of hobby horses by rightwing know-nothings we got when Pim Fortuyn was murdered. Certainly the media here in the Netherlands were filled to the brim with the sort of comments we saw two years ago, full of jeremiahads and dire warnings about the state of free speech and democracy in the Netherlands.

All bullshit.

Theo van Gogh was a provocateur, a shock jock, somebody who sought controverse as much because he relished it as out of genuine conviction. He was an arrogant crude bastard, one of those people, of whom we have had far too many these last two years, who thought freedom of speech meant being able to say anything he wanted, any way he wanted, without regard to the consequences. If you call an entire religion backward, call its adherents goatfuckers and make a movie about domestic violence in Islamic families which is deliberately provocking, by putting half nude women in see through burkas, their bodies painted with verses from the Koran, should you be surprised that somebody wants to kill you for this?

And of course what he wrote, said and filmed does not excuse his murder, no matter how provoking or insulting. However, his murder is not an attack on democracy or freedom of speech; it was far more personal than that. It looks more like a revenge killing, a honour killing.

Let’s not forget the context in which his murder took place. In the last three years or so years, especially after the murder of Pim Fortuyn, the political and cultural climate in the Netherlands has been one in which the right had appropriate to itself the right to talk as loudly and freely as it wanted to, without regards to consequences. Van Gogh was not hounded for his opinions; he was lauded for it. And his grandstanding did not do the cuase he was allegedly championing, domestic violence against Muslim women any good, when you realise his movie, if it had been made about domestic violence amongst Hassidic Jews, would’ve branded him an anti-semite. But because it is anti-Islam, anti-Muslim, it is all right.

If a genuine criticism could be made that until recently, too many existing problems had been taboos, could not be discussed, that there was too much tolerance in the Netherlands for things that should not be tolerated: crime, antisocial behaviour and the like, the last two years the pendulum has swung too far in the other direction. We have become too tolerant in the other direction when we have people saying things that are borderline or wholly racist and getting awy with it, with whole population groups –Muslims, immigrants, Moroccans– being demonised, blamed for the failure of the Dutch society to adjust them to it and it to them.

It is therefore not surprising that someone who by all accounts was already radicalised, somewhat of a nutter and who took his religion very serious, would be so insulted by van Gogh’s movie that he was wanted to kill van Gogh for this insult.

Condemn his murder, but do not make Theo van Gogh into a martyr of free speech. He wasn’t. He was killed because he insulted people, not because he told them the truth.

Too close to call and the twat concedes!

You cannot know how absolutely fucking angry I am right now. After four long years of incompetent leadership, after the biggest terrorist attack in the history of the US, one that could’ve been prevented, after four years of plunder, two years of an unnecessary war, an absolutely despicable election campaign waged by the Republicans, filled with more fraud then even 2000 saw, John “twat” Kerry thinks it’s a noble thing to concede before all the fucking votes are counted! Better for Kerry to have died forgotten in Vietnam than this shameful charade.

Kerry and the Democratic leadership have betrayed their party, their activists and their voters. Those who said Kerry was a false choice, who urged to vote third party, were right. Once again, when it comes to the crunch, the Democrats rolled over and died.

Thank you fucking much.

Squid profit from global warming

We may not like it, us poor folk in the Netherlands especially, but squid apparantely thrive on global warming, overtaking humans in biomass. Not only are there more squid, according to Dr George Jackson from the Institute of Antarctic and Southern Ocean they are also getting bigger:

“Many of the species have exponential growth, particularly during the juvenile stage so if you increase the water temperature by even a degree it has a tremendous snowballing effect of rapidly increasing their growth rate and their ultimate body size.

“They get much bigger and they can mature earlier and it just accelerates everything.”

The squid not only thrive on global warming, but also due to more direct interference by us. Since we seem intent on hunting their predators like tuna, to extinction, as well as their direct competitors, various finfish, squid can expand enormously. A good thing perhaps for them, not so good for the oceans’ ecology.

Also not good, the reports about Humboldt squid moving north into the waters around Alaska, when normally the furthest north they come is San Francisco. these squid are normally warm water animals, not suitable for living in colder waters (and indeed dying off in large numbers). The worry is, that this is happening because the warm water currents in the Pacific Ocean are shifting. And squid aren’t the only sea animals being found far north of their usual habitat: both thresher and great white sharks, as well as a hard-shell turtle and a jack mackarel have been sighted in Alaska recently…

Dead Men Left on The Guardian

James over at Dead Men Left has the perfect description of The Guardian’s attitude towards the US:

I think they see Americans as something like the rest of us see spiders: fine when behaving themselves and sitting quietly in the corner, but bloody terrifying when zooming around unpredictably at high speed, with no easy option but to stand on a chair and scream. It’s not an unreasonable fear if either beast should arrive with guns, I suppose, but the best thing to do with the particular breed of Republican spider the Guardian has run foul of is to follow the traditional rememdy: trap them in a box with a piece of paper and throw them outside the front door; or, failing that, end the occupation of Iraq.