Mundane Magic — Flying Witch

It takes a good ten minutes of the first episode of Flying Witch to actually show us a flying witch, and it’s done with a minimum of fuss:

Those first ten minutes are spent following Kowata Makoto as she travels from Yokohama to a small town in Aomori deep in the countryside, where she’s going to live with distant relatives as she enters high school. She’s picked up from the bus stop by her cousin, Kuramoto Kei, who still remembers how bad she is with directions from the last time they met, six years ago. While Kei and Makoto are immediately comfortable with each other, this is not the case with Kei’s little sister, Chinatsu. Especially after Chinatsu catches Makoto talking to her cat. She mellows out a bit though once she guides Makoto to the local shopping center and she’s treated to a donut. And then Makoto spots a line of brooms in the DIY centre and this scene happens. A magical moment, but a thoroughly mundane one. Especially when you compare it to similar scenes in Kiki’s Delivery Service or Little Witch Academia, Makoto’s first flight is a thoroughly subdued affair.

This is the strength of Flying Witch, treating magic and witchcraft not as something separate from everyday life, but instead having it rooted firmly in mundane concerns. Unlike most anime with magic in modern settings, it isn’t treated as something that has to be kept a secret. Witness the casual way Makoto landed herself in front of Kei when he was talking to somebody she didn’t know. Luckily it turned out to be Kei’s childhood friend Ishiwatari Nao, who took it all in stride. While Chinatsu is full of wonder of being able to fly and doesn’t stop laughing about it, Nao just has to pinch herself once. It’s not the last time Makoto will surprise her like this. While Kei is largely used to it and Chinatsu takes to witchcraft like a duck to water, Nao’s role is that of the straight man, having to put up with Makoto’s antics.

Nao is wonderful, and the best part is that there’s no hint of romance between her and Kei. Nor between Kei and Makoto. If there’s any chemistry, it’s between Kei and Akane, Makoto’s elder sister, but even that is more being comfortable around each other than anything else. There’s no romantic tension or subplot here whatsoever. Nor is there any fanservice. Or rather, no overt fanservice. No creepy camera angles, comedy gropings or excuses to have a swimsuit episode.

What further sets Flying Witch apart is how much it revolves around family rather than school life. Much of the series takes place either in or around the Kuramoto family home, or has Makoto going on outings with Kei, Chinatsu and Mao. Both Mao and Kei have their own lives as well and aren’t always present, though Chinatsu is. But then Chinatsu had quickly decided she wanted to be a witch herself. What makes this a rarity in anime is that Kei and Chinatsu’s parents are also frequently around. Not in any major role perhaps, but like how you’d expect to see your own parents at the weekend or in the evening.

Flying Witch‘s setting is super nostalgic for me by the way. I come from the same sort of backwater agricultural region here in the Netherlands, with all of my father’s family being farmers of some sort. (While he himself was a civil servant, farming’s still in his blood so he’s still running a Corbyn style allotment at 71.) The Kuramoto home has that same mingling of working and living spaces that I remember from visiting the family on Sundays, the same sort of slightly oldfashioned shabby chicness. Even the way Kei’s father has a much more heavier Amori accent than either his wife or children feels familiar. I bet any money that it’s the mother that does the book keeping. The village as well seems familiar, not as outrageously pretty as anime sometimes wants to showcase the Japanese countryside. Reminds me of those small villages in northern France you might ride through on the way to the actual tourist areas.

That groundedness makes the magic in Flying Witch look natural, but that doesn’t mean it lacks sense of wonder. As the series progresses, the magic the non-witch characters are exposed to can sometimes be amazing, sometimes frightening, as is the case with Chinatsu here. No matter how mundane Makoto’s use of magic is, there is a sense of larger powers slightly beyond the sight of ordinary people. There is never a sense of sustained dread however; the magic here is mostly benign. The way in which the series slowly reveals that larger world of magic while Makoto and her family go about their daily business makes this an excellent example of iyashikei. I enjoyed Flying Witch when it first aired and rewatching it only made me like it more. An underrated gem.

My ConZealand schedule

Had the world not taken a turn for the worse in January this year, I would’ve in Wellington now, in a very nice apartment that I had already booked just before everything shut down, ready for Worldcon to start. I’m still not sure I’ll ever get the money back from the flights I’d already booked as well, but ConZealand is going ahead anyway and I still will be on two panels. They’ll just be virtual ones, over Discord and Zoom, not that much different from how I’ve been doing my work the last five months already.

First up: My Favourite Anime: Our panellists reveal some of their favourite anime, and what draws them to it. 15:00, Friday 31 Jul 2020 NZST (50 minutes).

Second: The Decade in Anime: The highlights, the lowlights, and the unforgettable moments of 2010s anime. 14:00, Saturday 1 Aug 2020 NZST (50 minutes). Only disadvantage is that it overlaps a little bit with the Hugos.

Time wise, New Zealand is ten hours ahead of me, so that 15:00 and 14:00 starting time means I have to be up at 5AM and 4AM already. A small price to pay for being able to chatter on about anime.

Peter Green (29 October 1946 – 25 July 2020)

Fleetwood Mac co-founder Peter Green has passed away age 73. To be honest, I was under the impression he was dead already.



This is him playing my absolute favourite song from his version of Fleetwood Mac, “The Green Manalish”, which I first heard in Judas Priest’s version on Unleashed in the East. The original turned out to be even better. Priest’s one is fun but this is so much heavier and sinister. It’s always a bit sad to imagine what he could’ve been, what Fleetwood Mac could’ve been had he not taken that acid hit on tour in the same year this was filmed, had he not left the band. Don’t get me wrong, I like the Fleetwood Mac as it actually existed as well and Rumours is still the best album recorded by people who really shouldn’t have been in the same room together, but there was so much promise in Green’s version of the band as well. Imagine if it had kept up that heavy blues sound and refined it further. As it is, it took Fleetwood Mac the better part of a decade to get over his loss.

Transphobia has consequences

Sales of J. K. Rowling’s books in the US fell twenty percent short of the industry average:

Last month, sales in print books in fiction overall rose 31.4% in the U.S. from May, according to figures from NPD BookScan, with fiction titles in adult, young adult and juvenile sectors all seeing similar double-digit growth. The author of the “Harry Potter” series, by contrast, saw her print book sales in the U.S. rise just 10.9% in June. “Harry Potter” sales — including licensed titles not authored by Rowling — rose even less, just 7.7% for the month. While the BookScan figures do not account for other points of sale — like eBooks, sales to libraries and direct publisher sales — they do point to a remarkably sudden and sharp drop in print sales for Rowling’s books.

It seems that despite her habit of suing people for pointing out her transphobia, enough people have cottoned on to hurt her sales. Once again proving that the vast majority of people do not have any truck with transphobes.

Science fiction makes metaphors literal

And sometimes they’re not even metaphors, but shitty rightwing jokes about trans people, as Isabel Fall managed in her short story I Sexually Identify as an Attack Helicopter:

I sexually identify as an attack helicopter.

I lied. According to US Army Technical Manual 0, The Soldier as a System, “attack helicopter” is a gender identity, not a biological sex. My dog tags and Form 3349 say my body is an XX-karyotope somatic female.

So the original “joke” is that being trans or non-binary is so outrageous that you might as well call yourself an attack helicopter. What Isabel Fall does with it is in the best tradition of science fiction: taking that idea and exploring what it really means to have your gender set to attack helicopter. Not as a metaphor, but literally. Because that’s what science fiction does, making metaphors literal. Creating impossible things for its own merit, rather than as symbols standing in for real world concerns. Even as it’s always rooted in the real world and its contemporary issues, like this story is from its very title.

A shitty joke weaponised by bigots to harass trans people; the title isn’t neutral of course. Anybody who is trans or non-binary or genderqueer, or who like me, a well intentioned cis person, will hesitate on seeing that title, cringe and prepare for the worst kind of rightwing satire. My own concerns about this were lessened because a) I trusted the person who tweeted about the story not to be a transphobe and b) I trusted Clarkesworld were it appeared, not given to outbursts of transphobia as far as I know. After reading the story I knew it couldn’t have worked half as well under another title, but this does not take away the fact that for a lot of people it will make them suspicious or dismiss it out of hand of not worth reading. It explains some of the backlash against what was seemingly intended to tweak the nose of transphobes by making their one obnoxious joke real, by earnestly asking what if your gender was attack helicopter.

What would that mean? How would it express itself?

Now I yield to speed walkers in the hall like I need to avoid fouling my rotors.

Now walking beneath high-tension power lines makes me feel the way that a cis man would feel if he strutted down the street in a miniskirt and heels.

I’m comfortable in open spaces but only if there’s terrain to break it up. I hate conversations I haven’t started; I interrupt shamelessly so that I can make my point and leave.

At the same time this is obviously still a commentary on gender and gender dysphoria as experienced by a trans woman, as the writer has identified herself as, after the internet got hold of the story. You can no longer read this story. It has been taken offline on request of the writer, was scrubbed even from the Internet Archive afterwards. I started writing this review six months ago, in the first flush of enthusiasm after having read it. But then the backlash began as people took the title personal, as critics went on their first impression that this was a rightwing piss take, without checking to see if they were correct.

But how often—really—do you think about the grand strategy of gender? The mess of history and sociology, biology and game theory that gave rise to your pants and your hair and your salary? The casus belli?

Often, you might say. All the time. It haunts me.

There’s sometimes a tendency in queer circles to judge each other more harshly than necessary. You’d better be perfect, know exactly how to display and name your own identity, you’d better not be messy or unsure. A large part of that is a defence mechanism against homophobes and transphobes and other enemies, where any sign of uncertainty or not fitting quite in with the orthodoxy of what the trans|gay|lesbian|etc experience should be can be and has been used to attack the community. For trans people in the UK and US especially, the last few years have been tough, with their rights under renewed attack by the right, aided and abetted by quislings from within the communities, people who say they’re queer but want to kick the “T” out of LGBT. No wonder there’s so much mistrust and Isabel Fall became a victim of it. Alexandra Erin probably put it best in her her thread on why she wouldn’t read this story. I disagree with her, but she makes some good points on why not everybody saw this story as a triumph.

When I was a woman I wanted to be good at woman. I wanted to darken my eyes and strut in heels. I wanted to laugh from my throat when I was pleased, laugh so low that women would shiver in contentment down the block.

And at the same time I resented it all. I wanted to be sharper, stronger, a new-made thing, exquisite and formidable. Did I want that because I was taught to hate being a woman? Or because I hated being taught anything at all?

Now I am jointed inside. Now I am geared and shafted, I am a being of opposing torques. The noise I make is canceled by decibel killers so I am no louder than a woman laughing through two walls.

But the backlash went further than that. It wasn’t just that people got hurt by the story or its title despite the author’s intentions, it was that some people went to great pains to take offence at it and read it in the worst possible way. Where a J. K. Rowling could be openingly transphobic for years until a backlash here it only took hours before it was decided that Isabell Fall was a wrong one. Instead of criticising the story, it quickly devolving into attacking the author as a person, questioning her motivations with even some attempts to dox her. I hesitate to complain about “cancel culture” because usually it’s used to whinge about how people object to some rapist giving a speech at their uni, but this really felt like it. People taking offense and attacking a powerless, no-name trans woman because it would in some way make the world safer for trans women like the one you just raked over the coals. The end result is a deleted story and a writer whose career was snuffed out before it could begin.

And the moment their work reached a usable stage—the moment society was ready to accept plastic gender, and scientists were ready to manipulate it—the military found a new resource. Armed with functional connectome mapping and neural plastics, the military can make gender tactical.

Poor Isabel Fall. All she wanted to do was write a good, solid science fiction story that does what science fiction does best: concretalise metaphors to reflect the world around you. She succeeded, but at what cost to herself?