War lies: it’s not about the oil

It’s about the oil:

Iraqis face the dire prospect of losing up to $200bn (£116bn) of the wealth of their country if an American-inspired plan to hand over development of its oil reserves to US and British multinationals comes into force next year. A report produced by American and British pressure groups warns Iraq will be caught in an “old colonial trap” if it allows foreign companies to take a share of its vast energy reserves. The report is certain to reawaken fears that the real purpose of the 2003 war on Iraq was to ensure its oil came under Western control.

[…]

Earlier this year a BBC Newsnight report claimed to have uncovered documents showing the Bush administration made plans to secure Iraqi oil even before the 9/11 terrorist attacks on the US. Based on its analysis of PSAs in seven countries, it said multinationals would seek rates of return on their investment from 42 to 162 per cent, far in excess of typical 12 per cent rates.

Taking an assumption of $40 a barrel, below the current price of almost $60, and a likely contract term of 25 to 40 years, it said that Iraq stood to lose between £74bn and $194bn. Andrew Simms, the NEF’s policy director, said: “Over the last century, Britain and the US left a global trail of conflict, social upheaval and environmental damage as they sought to capture and control a disproportionate share of the world’s oil reserves. Now it seems they are determined to increase their ecological debts at Iraq’s expense. Instead of a new beginning, Iraq is caught in a very old colonial trap.”

I always said it, so this comes as no surprise to me. From the beginning, the Iraq war has been an excuse for corporate plundering; we all knew Iraq would not have been invaded if it didn’t have oil. In the past three years I’ve talked to a lot of people about the war and the overwhelming majority of people, regardless of their political stance, was convinced this war was fought for oil. So why was this such a controversial point before the war? Too many anti-war activists seemed reluctant at the time to draw attnetion to this point, especially the socalled moderates, probably out of fear of being called a hippy or “radical”. Heck, Henry Farrell still thinks it’s crackpot to think Bush knew before the war that Saddam had no weapons of mass destruction.

It is doubtful that this plan would be legal, even if implemented by the socalled independent Iraqi government rather than the US occupier, but the article also ignores that sooner or later the Americans will leave and the insurgency will take control of the country, at which point any such agreement will be null and void.

War lies: “German intelligence agree on Iraqi WMDs”

The greatest lies told about the war on Iraq are of course the lies about Saddam Hussein’s ties with Al Quida and his massive arsenal of weapons of mass destruction, lies that even at the time were hard to swallow and today only persist in hardcore Bushian circles and in the delusion bunker that is the Bush White House itself.

To cover up these lies in the aftermath of the invasion, once it became clear just how big those lies were and how little truth was in them, a new lie had to be invented. People like Tony Blair could no longer pretend to believe the prewar reports and instead resorted to a meta lie: “we misunderestimated the amounts of WMDs Iraq had, but everybody did” and “not just American and British intelligence was faulty, but the German and French intelligence services said the same things”.

The first charge is so much self serving nonsense. From the start, many if not most of the people against the war were sceptical about Saddam’s stash of WMDs — I know I was. And we had the support of people like Scott Ritter, the ex-weapons inspector who before the war made it clear these allegations were nonsense. The second claim is harder to reject, as funnily enough most intelligence services are reticent to talk about their work; you never know what information these services have that we do not. It makes it therefore easy for Blair to claim that they supported him before the war, that “we were all fooled” and that nobody is
to blame for this faulty intelligence.

Not anymore. The various investigations into the workings of MI5 and such in the wake of the death of Dr. David Kelly had already made much nonsense of Blair’s claims, but the final nail in the coffin might come from this report by the LA Times which shows that the CIA deliberately misrepresented German intelligence on Iraqi WMDs:

BERLIN — The German intelligence officials responsible for one of the most important informants on Saddam Hussein’s suspected weapons of mass destruction say that the Bush administration and the CIA repeatedly exaggerated his claims during the run-up to the war in Iraq.

Five senior officials from Germany’s Federal Intelligence Service, or BND, said in interviews with The Times that they warned U.S. intelligence authorities that the source, an Iraqi defector code-named Curveball, never claimed to produce germ weapons and never saw anyone else do so.

According to the Germans, President Bush mischaracterized Curveball’s information when he warned before the war that Iraq had at least seven mobile factories brewing biological poisons. Then-Secretary of State Colin L. Powell also misstated Curveball’s accounts in his prewar presentation to the United Nations on Feb. 5, 2003, the Germans said.

Curveball’s German handlers for the last six years said his information was often vague, mostly secondhand and impossible to confirm.

“This was not substantial evidence,” said a senior German intelligence official. “We made clear we could not verify the things he said.”

The German authorities, speaking about the case for the first time, also said that their informant suffered from emotional and mental problems. “He is not a stable, psychologically stable guy,” said a BND official who supervised the case. “He is not a completely normal person,” agreed a BND analyst.

Worse, those within the CIA who questioned this intelligence were ignored and punished for their views:

An investigation by The Times based on interviews since May with about 30 current and former intelligence officials in the U.S., Germany, England, Iraq and the United Nations, as well as other experts, shows that U.S. bungling in the Curveball case was worse than official reports have disclosed.

The White House, for example, ignored evidence gathered by United Nations weapons inspectors shortly before the war that disproved Curveball’s account. Bush and his aides issued increasingly dire warnings about Iraq’s biological weapons before the war even though intelligence from Curveball had not changed in two years.

At the Central Intelligence Agency, officials embraced Curveball’s account even though they could not confirm it or interview him until a year after the invasion. They ignored multiple warnings about his reliability before the war, punished in-house critics who provided proof that he had lied and refused to admit error until May 2004, 14 months after the invasion.

one of the victims of the Iraq war
One of the victims that need not have died if these people had done their job before the war.

Which leaves one important question: why did the German intelligence services or those CIA people who questioned Curveball not come forward before the war, when it might have done some good? You might also ask why the LA Times couldn’t have mounted this investigation then, come to think of it. Some 100,000 Iraqi people might still be alive if either party had deigned to blow the whistle earlier.

Kate Bush: countdown to Aerial

I’m not a Kate Bush fan; I got one album Hounds of Love and like the obvious singles (“Wuthering Heights”, “Running up That Hill” “Cloudbuster”) but that’s it. Reinder Dijkhuis on the other hand is enough of a fan to have all her albums. In honour of the upcoming release of her new album, Aerial, he has provided reviews of all her albums:

  • Countdown to Aerial 1: The Kick Inside
    I have no memory of a world without Kate Bush’s music. I suppose it must have been 1978 or 1980 when I first heard “Wuthering Heights”, and my musical memories simply don’t stretch back much further. I’ve pretty much always been a fan of her work, even when I only knew it as “that strange song with the high voice”.
  • Countdown to Aerial 2: Lionheart
    It’s true, I’ll admit, that Kate’s second record doesn’t surprise the way her debut does, but on its own
    merits, it’s a very strong album. There’s no sense at all that the songs were mere leftovers from the previous batch – more likely they were deliberately kept in reserve.
  • Countdown to Aerial 3: Never For Ever
    Never For Ever has quite a few rocking moments (she sounds like Nina Hagen in “Violin” and “The Wedding List”) and uses dynamics and crescendo a lot in the arrangements, so playing it at high volume definitely improves it.
  • Countdown to Aerial 4: The Dreaming
    The Dreaming is not merely the best Kate Bush record; it’s THE BEST RECORD EVER MADE BY ANYONE IN THE HISTORY OF POPULAR MUSIC!!! It’s perfect from beginning to end: strange, innovative, melodic, exciting, packed with raw emotion, violence and clever storytelling. It also has Kate braying like a donkey.
  • Countdown to Aerial 5: Hounds of Love
    Hounds of Love, then, is really two great albums compressed into 40-odd minutes’ playing time. It’s essential. The 1997 remaster has a few bonus tracks that are okay; a bit of a grab bag to be honest.
  • Countdown to Aerial 6: The Sensual World
    There’s plenty that’s good on the record though. The title track is lush and erotic – Kate is probably the only arranger who can make uillean pipes sound sexy.
  • Countdown to Aerial 7: The Red Shoes
    […]on the whole, The Red Shoes is listenable. It gets the odd spin at the studio, from people other than me, even. It just… doesn’t grab, doesn’t irritate, doesn’t connect.
  • Countdown to Aerial 8: Aerial
    For the most part, though, the album sticks to the background, prettily washing over this one listener
    just like much of the previous record did. There is, on the whole, more to pique the interest in the first
    disk, the collection of Kate songs, than in the second, conceptual one, but in both, there simply isn’t enough.

Victory for the Shell strikers?

strikers at Shell

Last week Shell workers went on strike to keep their retirement rights. It did not take long for Shell to cave in (link in Dutch) under the threat of closing down production at the refineries at Pernis, “Europe’s largest”.

The unions fought to keep the retirement age for current employees at 60 as well as to force the company to keep paying the entire pension premiums. In the new agreement with Shell, they have largely though not entirely gotten what they wanted. For current employees, retirement age will stay at 60, but the official retirement age will still become 65. To bridge the gap between 60 and 65, there’s the “levensloopregeling”, which is a new savingsplan introduced by the Dutch government this year, through which you can save up part of your wages before taxes to either take early retirement or unpaid leave, with wage taxes defered to the moment you actual start using the fund. Shell has now pledged to annually pay 6.5 % of each worker’s income into this fund, instead of the 3 % it had first offered. By trading in two vacation days, each employee can add another 1.5 % annually as well. However, the Shell workers will have to start contributing to their retirement funds: 2/5 of their wages.

So, a victory for the Shell strikers? Or could more have been achieved with a more hardline attitude?