Chagos islanders win court victory

Three years ago I wrote about the plight of the Chagos islanders, who were kicked out of their archipelo back in the sixties to make way for the enormous US military base of Diego Garcia, located on the largest island of the Chagos archipelo. The Chagos islands were then and still are now a colony of the UK and it was the UK government who forcibly removed, “compensated” and dumped the inhabitants, the Ilois, in Mauritius, recently made independent. That would’ve been the end of it, if not for the incredible determination of the Ilois, who are still fighting for the right to return to their islands.

And that right came a step closer this week when they won a High Court judgment, which ruled that their removal was illegal. However, since it also granted the government the right to appeal, this is not the end of it. Also, even if this judgment is not appealed against, there are still other hurdles for them to jump through: the US has already stated it will not allow any of the islanders to return no matter what the UK courts decide…

China Miéville wins Clarke Award

Via Lenin’s Tomb comes the news that China Miéville has won the 2005 Arthur C. Clarke Award for his 2004 novel Iron Council. According to the Clarke Award’s administrator Paul Kincaid:

“Iron Council by China Miéville focuses sharply on political change, but note how many things feed into
that change: wealth and suffering and sexuality and hope. This is the point at which the conflict between the moral and the political which has underpinned his previous books bursts into the open. There are many wrongs in Miéville’s world, but very few rights, and politics in all its forms from simple co-operation to bloody revolution, is shown to be the frail and fallible attempt to find a way in the world. And in the last few dramatic pages, this is a novel about closing Pandora’s Box because of the necessity of preserving hope.

Iron Council is also still up for the Hugo Awards. So far however, not one Clarke Award winner has gone on to win the Hugo as well; might Iron Council be the first?

Living Marxism watch

It is interesting how often the erstwhile comrades of Living Marxism manage to be cited in the British media to spout their obsession with risk aversion

Case in point. Here we have Frank Furedi, the ex-Living Marxism, ex-Revolutionary Communist Party guru, on the subject of “smug parents” in last week’s Observer:

‘The situation is compounded because we have privatised childcare. It is no longer the responsibility of
society to look after the next generation but the sole responsibility of individuals who feel that they
must parent all the time.’ […]

‘This means that there is now a threat that this can define you completely. Your personality is no longer comprised of what job you do, what films you like or cultural references — being a parent becomes your whole identity and you live your life through your kids.’

What annoys me is not necessarily there relentless banging of their obsessions, but the fact that the British newsmedia presents Furedi and co as neutral experts on whatever topic they’re asked their opinion on, without acknowledgement of the specific political agenda behind their opinions. (Take for example this potted BBC profile of Claire Fox. Nothing about what her “Institute of Ideas” stands for.)

Labour caught redhanded?

I think Dead Men Left is right when he suspects the “student Benjamin Virgo, 34” in this story:

Elsewhere in Bethnal Green, student Benjamin Virgo, 34, explained what had happened to him on Tuesday night. ‘On the way out to the corner shop to buy milk and bread I passed a couple of young guys. After I’d crossed the road they threw a bottle at me. They became more aggressive, so I reached for my mobile and started to call the police. They followed me into the shop and announced to the other customers and staff that I was a racist. Then, fists in my face, they ordered me to stop my call, reminded me that they knew where I lived and threatened to burn my house down. The police never came. George Galloway is now my MP.’

Is the same as the “Ben Virgo, 34” who is “studying classics at UCL” in this story:

Meet the Virgos from Bethnal Green. Ben, 34, used to work in the City, but he gave it up to become a
drugs counsellor, and now he’s studying classics at UCL. His wife Rachel teaches part time at a local
primary school. They have three lovely children, Gilbert, five, Theo, three and Albany, one. They seem,
by all outward appearances, a rather ordinary domestic collective, but last week the media dubbed them “Labour’s rent-a-crowd” when they were pictured standing behind the prime minister and the chancellor at a poster launch. Elements of the so-called Virgo family, it transpired, had also appeared at a previous Labour launch. They were there, according to one commentator, as part of a “human shield of party activists” designed to protect Blair from journalists. The Daily Mail went so far as to described the atmosphere of the event as “redolent of the old Soviet Union”.

The smoking gun turns up in the middle of the article:

[…]It all began with a letter to their local MP, in their case Oona King, asking her to help them in their quest for a larger council flat.

Coincidence? I think not

Oona King uses pensioner in smear campaign against Respect

Oona King shamefully using an attacked pensioner to smear Respect

Over at the pro-war left’s hiding holes the usual suspects have been lapping up a story about an alleged attack on a pensioner by Respect supporters leafletting for George Galloway. Unfortunately for them, this story seems to have been made up out of whole cloth by Oona King’s campaign team or some other interested party, as none of the details of the attack ring true.


The claim
:

Mr Les Dobrovolski, 69, was approached by a group of young men handing out George Galloway’s Respect/ SWP literature, last Thursday 21 April, near Spitalfield Market in East London.

After refusing to take a leaflet and telling the men he would never vote for George Galloway, Mr
Dobrovolski says he was followed by one of the men and pushed to the floor. The man then stamped on his hand before dropping a Respect leaflet on him and running off.

Mr Dobrovolski was taken by ambulance to the local hospital where he was x-rayed and given stitches.
He is scheduled to return to hospital next week for surgery to straighten his broken nose. The police
were informed of the attack and are currently investigating.

Now the facts, courtesy of Lenin’s Tomb

On Thursday 21st April, Les Dobrovolski told the police that he had been attacked, but there was no
mention of him having been assaulted by Respect supporters or of any leaflet. The first time such a
claim appeared anywhere was in the Labour Party’s press-release. The police have confirmed, categorically, that no such claims were made to the police when Mr Dobrovolski was interviewed, and that they are not investigating the Respect party in connection with this. They issued it as a general statement to the press, which is why most papers did not touch it.

The claim that Mr Dobrovolski encountered Respect supporters canvassing for George Galloway in Poplar is highly improbable, to say the least, since Poplar is not in the constituency being contested by
George Galloway. There were no canvassers out there. The leaflet that was allegedly dropped on Mr
Dobrovolski following the attack was still in the printers on the day of the attack, and was sent out
as a postal drop – ie, sent by the printers directly to Royal Mail, and not to Respect leaders or
canvassers. The earliest the leaflet could have been sent out was on Saturday’s post.

Do keep in mind Oona King already had to settle out of court once for a libel action George Galloway brought against her, only to repeat the libel almost immediately afterwards. Since the start of campaigning she has been trying to make the race as nasty as possible, constantly smearing Respect and Galloway; this fits in perfectly.

The smear itself is bad enough, but to use a bystander, a pensioner in a dirty war against Respect is
quite something else.