Godwin’s law misused again


As a Usenet discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches one.”

You see the above? That is Godwin’s law. Nothing more, nothing less. It does not mean that you can never bring up nazis or Hitler, can never compare someone or something to them or that you automatically lose a discussion if you do so.

Unfortunately, too many people act like it does.

Case in point, those objecting to Nathan Newman’s post comparing Israel’s treatment of the Palestines to Nazi Germany in 1938. As I’ve argued myself, comparisons of Israel with Nazi Germany are usually counterproductive and offensive, but not in this case. Yes, it is inflammary, but largely correct as well. To then scream “Godwin! Godwin! You lose!” is obnoxious.

Bigotry or just obnoxiousness?

One of my bêtes noirs is anti-French bigotry, which for some reason USAnians are most likely to indulge in (with UKians a close second). The litany is familiar: they’re whiny, arrogant, stinkyand cowardly; the sort of lazy stereotypes any good bigot has ready to hurl at their favourite target.

In the current political climate, with France taking a stance against the mad plans Bush has for Iraq, it’s no surprise hatred of the French has gone mainstream again. Not a day goes by without some pundit getting a dig in at the perfide French. For the most part, this is coming from people who are beyond redemption anyway, so it doesn’t really bother me. However, when it’s somebody who’s normally more sensible than that, somebody who’s not a rightwing nutbar, somebody like Jim Capozzola from The Rittenhouse Review, it gets my goat.

Jim thought it would be funny to post one of thoes mass forwarde e-mails, something called The Complete Military History of France –I bet you know already where this is going, right? Correct, it’s a “hilarious” summing up of all the wars France was in and how bad they were. A real kneeslapper. It features such gems as:

Hundred Years War: Mostly lost. Saved at last moment by a schizophrenic teenaged girl, who inadvertently creates The First Rule of French Warfare: “France’s armies are victorious only when not led by a Frenchman.”


(Why did you link “schizophrenic teenaged girl” to Body and Soul, btw?)

Duh! Because she posts as Jeanne D’Arc, of course, as Jim has pointed out to me. sometimes I am an idiot.

World War I: Tied and on the way to losing, France is saved by the United States. Thousands of French women find out what it’s like to not only sleep with a winner, but one who doesn’t call her “Fraulein.” Sadly, widespread use of condoms by American forces forestalls any improvement in the French bloodline.

World War II: Lost. Conquered French liberated by the United States and Britain just as they finish learning the Horst Wessel Song.

In short, it betrays not only a astonishing lack of historical knowledge, it’s also incredibly offensive. If you don’t agree with me, do a gedankenexperiment and imagine the response a similar list with examples of “Jewish greed” would get.

Apart from the offensiveness of statements like “Going to war without the French is like . . . well . . . World War II” –Word War II did not start in 1941, you know– what irritates me as much is the smugness of the whole “essay”. It is drenched in a sence of superiority which is wholly unearned: when was the last time the US fought a serious war on its own territory or had a real, strong enemy at its borders? The US has not had to deal with anything like the amount of war and devastation France had to; I sincerily doubt it would’ve done better.

UPDATE: edited to make it clear Jim only posted this, not wrote it. He has e-mailed me (after I notified him) that the main reason he posted it was because he’s always the last to recieve such
forwards:

Actually, the reason I posted it wasn’t because I hate the French or anything, though I’m no fan, but because — as I’ve said on my blog several times — I’m usually the last person in the world to receive
e-mails with those kinds of world-traveling “humor” pieces. I was trying, at least, to make fun of myself, not the French, though that seems to have escaped nearly everyone who read it.

Fair enough. Obviously, it has somewhat backfired… Let me make clear that I don’t think Jim is a bigot at all; his post just irked me enough to rant about the attitude as displayed in that piece.

Google buys blogger

From a story done for the San Jose Mercury News and reported on Dan Gillmor’s weblog:

But now Google will surge to the forefront of what David Krane, the company’s director of corporate communications, called “a global self- publishing phenomenon that connects Internet users with dynamic, diverse points of view while also enabling comment and participation.”

“We’re thrilled about the many synergies and future opportunities between our two companies,” he said in a statement on Saturday. He didn’t elaborate further on what those synergies and opportunities might be, but said more details would emerge soon. Users of the Blogger software and hosting service won’t see any immediate changes, he added.

For Williams and his five co-workers, now Google employees, the immediate impact will be to put their blog-hosting service, called Blog*Spot, on the vast network of server computers Google operates. This will make the service more reliable and robust.

That last is good news at least. For the rest we’ll have to wait and see, but if there’s one company I trust not to fuck things up, it’s Google.

Just another day in the War against Drugs

You probably have seen this story elsewhere, about the 19 year old kid who got 26 years in jail for
selling marijuana
:

Alexander was 18, a senior at Lawrence County High with two classes left before graduation. The “new kid” turned out to be an undercover drug agent. And four sales, together worth about $350, landed Alexander a 26-year prison sentence.

Which is bad enough and has been the cause of much outrage and astonishment in the blogworld. But if you read on, it gets worse:

Alexander was not arrested with marijuana at school. Prosecutors secured enhancements on his sentence because of a state law that adds five years when someone sells drugs within three miles of a school or housing project.
Though on an isolated country stretch, the Alexanders’ property met both standards.

Now I can understand the law being tougher on people selling (illegal) drugs to minors, but this sort of automatic sentencing is just silly, as you can see in this case. This is a case of a teenager selling dope to other teenagers, not an evil drugs dealer addicting kindergarten kids. That the place of the “crime” was in technically in the limits but in reality fairly isolated makes it all the more absurd.

He doesn’t deny he sold marijuana. It was easy money. But authorities’ depiction of him as some sort of kingpin is far from the truth, he said. “I’ve been in maybe one fight in school my whole life, and now I’m sentenced to 26 years in the pen,” he said. “That doesn’t make any sense to me.”

After his arrest and expulsion, Alexander found a private school where he completed his classes and got a high school diploma. He also graduated from a drug treatment program, found a job as a bricklayer and enrolled in Calhoun Community College.

In other words, even after his life got ruined and with the threat of along prison sentence hanging over him he’s doing quite well. Doesn’t sound like a dangerous criminal who needs to be kept away from society, does he?

But what lead to Alexander’s arrest in the first place? Overzealous school officials.

The crackdown that led to Alexander’s arrest began soon after Ricky Nichols took over as principal in fall 2001.

Nichols, an Army Reservist who target-shoots with sheriff’s deputies, considers himself a front-line soldier in the war on drugs. His training includes police courses on drug identification. The drug task force has given him pointers on searching students’ cars for contraband.

Once a girl came in the school office asking for aspirin. She admitted having a hangover and failed a breath test. Nichols searched her car. “She didn’t really have a choice,” he said. “I don’t have to have probable cause. The police have to have probable cause.”

Glad I went to school in a sane country. Sure, drugs prevention should be part of a principal’s job, but car searches? Undercover police officiers? In this sort of fascistoid climate it’s easy to justify hitting a teenager with a prison sentence longer then he has been alive, for a “crime” that didn’t hurt anybody, which is only a crime because the government choose to make it a crime, not because it’s inherently immoral.

Auntie Beeb

Chris Bertram is talking about the BBC on his weblog, after he recieved a link from the Biased BBC weblog. He notes some things I’m annoyed with as well:

So what do I think about the BBC? I’m not particularly keen on the way it is financed (by a regressive poll tax) and I’m sure that will change given the multiplication of channels. The BBC’s current position strikes me as untenable given the way it uses the licence fee to subsidise its aggressive competition with the private sector via ventures such as BBC Choice, BBC4, BBC Style, BBC Everything Else and in the magazine market with its range of music, gardening, history etc etc offerings. I think I’m right in saying that they’ve now been barred from surreptitiously advertising some of these products on their main TV channels, but, all the same, magazines like History Today have to compete in a market against a product bearing the imprimatur of the prestigious public service broadcaster and containing numerous TV tie- ins, listings and so on. That strikes me as unfair.

I don’t really agree on the licence fee, as it does make the BBC more independent from the government than if they had to depend on funding from general taxes. I was against the similar arrangment we had here, true, but that was because we had the worst of both worlds: a licence fee *and* lots of commercials.

As for Chris’ other points, I quite agree. I get very annoyed with the amount of advertising the BBC does themselves for channels I’ll never see and I do think the BBC has gone too commercial in the last five years or so: BBC World e.g. is nothing but a rebranded CNN with british accents. I also think the quality of the two main channels has drastically gone down: too much socalled reality programmes showing some rich upper class twits getting their life laundried or their gardens the size of Devon redone or buying a second home, a small little castle near Windsor. The less said about [fx: annoying Scottish accent]Fame Academy[/fx] the better. And spare me Pauline “can’t act, can annoy” Quirk, please. However, Chris has a point when he says:

At the same time, I thing a great deal of what the BBC produces (like the Robert Hughes programme on Gaudi and the documentary on Algeria I mentioned recently) is really great stuff. And a lot of the best drama of recent years has been on the BBC (would Denis Potter ever have gone so far without it?). Channel 4 used to provide an alternative arena for good programming, but in recent years it has become dominated by reality TV, crap gameshows, chat programmes from hell and other dross (yes, even more than the BBC).

The strength of the BBC at the moment seems to me to lie in its non-fiction programmes. Series like “What did the Victorians do for us?”, “The Blue Planet” or “Life of Mammals” are just plain brilliant and it’s hard to see any other tv channel doing them.