Holland was safe. Safe behind the dykes

Even if you know next to nothing about the Netherlands, you know that our history has been one of struggle, a continuing struggle against the sea and its might. It is only a slight exaggeration to say that we conquered this country from the sea, polder by polder and dyke by dyke. Even in the earliest mention of what once would become our country, in the works of the Roman historian Pliny the Elder this struggle was evident, as he spoke of “a people living between water and land”.

More than a quarter of the country lies below the waterline and would flood if there weren’t dykes and dunes to keep the sea out. You see, the western and especially the south western part of the country, the part I’m from, is nothing more then a massive delta, a place where three of Europe’s great rivers come together: the Rhine, the Schelde and the Meuse, flowing into each other and into the sea, creating a borderland of islands and estuaries: Zeeland, “sealand”.

Yes, the force of the sea was well known, as flood after flood had made clear through the centuries. But by 1953 all this had changed. Thanks to the high modern dykes, the risk of another flood was minimal. The last serious flood, in 1944, had not even been a natural disaster, but was caused by the Allies bombing the dykes of Walcheren –which dominated the approach to the vital harbour of Antwerpen– to flood out the Germans. Since then, the dykes and dunes had been repaired and rebuild:
Holland was safe again.

Until that fateful moment, today exactly fifty years ago, when during the night and onto the next morning it turned out the dykes weren’t high and strong enough and the North Sea delivered a nasty surprise to the Dutch South West. On that day, the worst flood, the worst natural disaster in Dutch modern history began. Before it was under control, 1835 people would be dead, some 750,0000 people were affected; many lost their homes, had to be evacuated, had to flee the coming water with nothing more than the clothes on their backs. The amount of livestock lost is unknown, but must number in the (tens of) thousands. Material damage was unmeasurable. Below is a map of the afflicted area:

a map of the area hit by the flood

Over the next few days I would like to tell the story of the disaster, the relief operations and its aftermath here at Wis[s]e Words. The disaster is one of the events that has shaped modern Holland, both figurally but aslo literally, as after the disaster drastic steps were undertaken to ensure it would never happen again. It is a story I find worth telling, hopefully y’all will find it worth reading as well.

Gretta Duisenberg

If you’re involved in political campaigns, you know there are always a few people on your side whose heart is in the right place, whose dedication is absolute, but who are absolutely the last persons you should trust to argue your point of views, because they will fuck it up. Gretta Duisenberg is one of them.

For those who don’t know her, she campaigns for Israel to withdraw from the Occupied Territories and for the right of the Palestinian population to self determination. A cause which has my sympathy as well. Unfortunately, she has an incredible tin ear, lacks tact and has a tendency to speak before she thinks. She first came in the news when she flew a Palestinian flag from her Amsterdam home, something which her Jewish neighbours took umbrage with. In her attempts to resolve the situation, she showed herself to be less than tactful.

Recently, she canalised her unease with the situation into real action and went on a mission to Israel and the Occupied Teritories with the Dutch Stop the Occupation action group and again became the centre of a row. In an interview with a Dutch newspaper, she stated that “with the exception of the Holocaust, the Israeli occupation of the Palestinian areas is worse than the Nazi occupation of the Netherlands“, which may not be the stupidest thing you can say on the subject, but certainly comes close.

It’s not that Gretta Duisenberg is an anti-semite –at least not as far as I know– it’s just that she has a poor impulse control and doesn’t think before she says something. Quite apart from the inherent tackiness of Nazi comperisions (especially in this context!), it just isn’t true. Taking the Holocaust out of the equation is as silly as saying that with the exception of the WTC attacks, Al Quaida has not managed to kill many Americans.

Furthermore, the best way to get neutral people to stop listening to you and think of you as either a kook or an anti-semite is comparing Israel to the Nazies. It is borderline anti-semitic, it denigrates the Holocaust and it makes you look like an ahistorical dork. Israel’s occupation is awful and the suffering it causes innocent Palestinians is wrong, wrong, wrong, but it’s not genocidal. Israel is comparable to Apartheid era South Africa, not to Nazi Germany, like South Africa it can change. But it won’t happen because of Gretta Duisenberg, if she continues this way.

What also irritates me is how she, just because she’s the wife of the president of the European Central Bank gets all this media attention. If she was more competent it wouldn’t be such a problem, but because of her antics she’s doing quite a lot of damage to the cause she supposedly supports.

Gorey matters

No, I ain’t dead yet, just busy with the election campaign. Next Wednesday is the big day, when we’ll see who gets voted into Parliament this time and whether the new government will last longer than 86 days… I’ve also been on holiday and had little time for blogging then either.

While I’m busy campaigning, shoving flyers through letterboxes, freezing my nuts off standing behind a stall in the market explaining why you should vote SP, why don’t you take a a look at Goreyography? Yep, you guessed right, it’s a website dedicated to the weird and wonderful works of Edward Gorey, author and artist. There’s also a Gorey font if you like that sort of thing. Both found by Sandra.

Oh and please: Turn your Back on Bush

Schadenfreude

So the much lauded rightwing coalition of CDA (Christian democrats), VVD (neoliberals) and LPF (idiots, mostly) has collapsed. Oh dear. And I was sooo enjoying the LPF soap.

So what happened to the Revolution, the New Politics the LPF would bring? What happened to Pim Fortuyn’s heritage? Well, it turned out that stuffing a party full of nitwits, egotrippers and cocky businessmen is not a good idea. Without Pim Fortuyn as leader to guide them, power struggles erupted. The party had no vision, no experience and no leader. It was part of a coalition with the two parties with the worst reputation for power games, whom both had long experience in keeping coalition partners down. The LPF never had a chance.

All of which means there will be new elections soon. Until then, there’s nobody governing the country and important decisions cannot be taken… What this will mean for the upcoming decision about extension of the EU, to which the Netherlands has to give its consent, is anybody’s guess.

Objectivists defend blacklisting

I was idly googling on Michael Italie, the sewing machine operator and SWP member who was fired from his job at Goodwill after he ran for mayor of Miami, when I came across this gem: The Importance of Blacklisting, hosted at the Objectivist Center.

In this article, one Roger Donway describes the case of Michael Italie and argues that Goodwill was in their right to fire him, that in fact this was a tactict objectivists should emulate. He argues that blacklisting is justified in defending “bourgeois standards”:

The central issue of the Goodwill case has nothing to do with the right of free speech or the right to run for office, for those rights were not touched. The central issue of the Goodwill case is nothing but the right of citizens to weaken their destroyers by refusing to fund them. Of course, when alumni and employers withdraw their money, Marxist professors and anti-capitalist employees will whine, “Don’t I have a right to my own opinion?” To which the proper answer is: “Yes. And I’ll be happy to debate your opinion, if I have time. Meanwhile, I decline to support those who attack the political-economic system that makes my support possible.”


[…]

Consequently, I believe that libertarians should openly align themselves with the philosophical advocates of bourgeois morality, whatever the cost in popularity may be. They should point out that a major virtue of abolishing government regulation and subsidies will be a greater need for rationality, personal responsibility, and productiveness; a greater need for prudence, sobriety, and thrift; a greater concern for one’s own reputation and a greater reliance on the reputations of others, with a corresponding esteem for those behaviors — patriotism and cultural assimilation, marriage and child- rearing, decorum in conduct, speech, and appearance–that are commonly thought to be indicators of personal solidity.

But libertarians should go further still. They should also urge plausible, non- political mechanisms –ostracism, boycott, and blacklist–that will impose severe costs on those who flout bourgeois standards.

In short, Dunway argues punishing people for their political beliefs by taking away their livelyhood is okay, that objectivists should in fact use this tactic to “defund the Left”. Pretty vile, if you ask me. It’s typical of a certain breed of Libertarian: quick to claim the moral high ground, though their deeds are anything but moral.