Not sure what to think about this

The Washington Post looking into the data sets Google uses to train its chatbots and some surprising results popped up:

A screenshot from the article showing cloggie.org is present in the data set with 230 tokes and rank 11,780,115

As The Post put it:

To look inside this black box, we analyzed Google’s C4 data set, a massive snapshot of the contents of 15 million websites that have been used to instruct some high-profile English-language AIs, called large language models, including Google’s T5 and Facebook’s LLaMA. (OpenAI does not disclose what datasets it uses to train the models backing its popular chatbot, ChatGPT)
The Post worked with researchers at the Allen Institute for AI on this investigation and categorized the websites using data from Similarweb, a web analytics company. About a third of the websites could not be categorized, mostly because they no longer appear on the internet. Those are not shown.
We then ranked the remaining 10 million websites based on how many “tokens” appeared from each in the data set. Tokens are small bits of text used to process disorganized information — typically a word or phrase.

Because the article kindly included a search bar I found out my website is also included in the data set, with some 230 tokens. It would be interesting to see what exactly was included in those 230 tokens from the more than two decades of rambling contained in this site. Sadly, that’s not provided here. Nevertheless, an interesting look in the data used in training socalled AI programmes and its limitations.

This blog is old enough to drink in America

Its very first post was a rather pedestrian piece on a group of Dutch right wing population reduction enthusiasts, starting a long tradition of earnest mediocrity. At that point I had already run my booklog for more than a year but that stage it had been very much just a web page rather than an actual blog. Blogs themselves had slowly evolved from out of the primordial web ooze from the late nineties and thanks to certain things happening in September of the previous year, had suddenly become the Next Big Internet Thing. Me, I still thought of Usenet as the most important part of the internet, the space where I’d made my friends and life long connections.

It’s hard to remember in this post-blogging, everybody easily shove their thoughts in your face, social media world how weird and exciting blogging was. A bit scary too. I knew how to create web pages, had had Cloggie.org since 1999, a descendant of older, long gone student web sites, but those were all just basic HTML and CSS rigs, not using scary things like PHP or Javascript to make it all fancy. WordPress, which I’m currently using, didn’t exist yet. Blogger did but only allowed you to publish on their blogger.com site, if I remember correctly. There didn’t seem to exist any sort of lightweight, standalone blogging suite that I could plug into Cloggie.org easily.

Until Charlie Stross introduced me to Blosxom, when he launched his blog. That was ideal. Free, simple, easy to understand even for a dim bulb like me. The only thing you needed to do was write a post as a text file, HTMl and all, then drop it on your website using FTP. It was simple enough to finally get me started blogging, something I’d been itching to do ever since I’d started reading blogs myself. It lasted me a year or so, then I switched to phposxom, a similar concept but somewhat of an improvement, with slightly improved features. Ultimately that too would be too limited and I finally switched over to WordPress somewhere in 2008.

This blog is so old it’s older than Eschaton: Atrios only got started in April. It’s old enough to have covered the 50th, 60th and 70th anniversary of the Watersnoodramp. Old enough to have survived multiple blogging software updates and the demise of several, once critical blogging components. Remember Haloscan comments? Technorati rankings? Google Reader? it was a year old when the War on Iraq started and indeed the buildup to that war was a major reason I started it in the first place. It has swung from being a general interest to an intensely political blog and back again several times. It’s old enough to remember when Matt Yglesias was just a hack blogger and watch in horror while people like him used blogs as a step on the way to become even hackier pundits, still wrong on everything but on a much larger scale while those who got The War on Iraq right languished.

This is not a blog that is read much, not even when it had its popular phase. Most of the links in it don’t work anymore and sometimes even I don’t know anymore what I was talking about because it. There never were that many commenters, nor a real community like some of the larger blogs could establish. Many of the comments that were made where lost when Haloscan went under, again a chunk of its history and context lost. There is no real reason for it to exist, no grift attached, nothing to promote, no real audience it is chasing.

Calvin under a black starry sky: I'm significant. Said the dust speck.

If there is a reason for this blog to exist, it is to simply say: “I exist. This is what I find important. This happened. I matter.

Boekenbeurs 1982 — 2023

So many of the books on my bookshelves came from this place:

Front view of a bookstore with books stalled out in front of the shop window sheltered by a canopy above them

I used to have a set routine growing up in Middelburg in the eighties. Every other Saturday morning or so I would go to the local library, sometimes together with my mother, then on the way back home stop at this place, De Boekenbeurs, which was located just across the bridge from the library. There I would spent an hour or so carefully looking over its selections of secondhand science fiction and comics, deciding on what to buy now and what might still be available next time before parting with my hard earned pocket money. It was about the only bookstore in town that did carry science fiction and certainly the only one that a broke teenager like me could afford. After I moved to Amsterdam I’d still continue to visit every time I was back in my hometown because nine times out of ten I would find something interesting there. I did just that when I was visiting my parents for Christmas last December, but I won’t be able to anymore next time I visit, as today is its last opening.

It’s a familiar story for any independent bookstore I’d guess. De Boekenbeurs opened in 1982, founded by an ex-civil servant who wanted to strike out for himself. As many local bookstores, it always specialised in local history and such, most of which was of little interest to me, but it also kept more generic stock to fill its shelves. There was always a good chance of finding some unexpected gem among the airport thrillers and local celeb biographies. And then of course the internet happened, people found it easier to get their books online and the sort of serendipitous browsing that a local shop like that is ideal for fell out of fashion. The store reduced its opening hours, started selling online as well, but it was clear that, especially in the last few years, it had become a struggle for the owner, no longer that much fun. Which is why he decided to shut up shop, not having been able to find a buyer for it.

Nevertheless it managed to stay in business for forty years and a bit and I have been coming there almost as long. It was a life line for a nerd like me at a time when opportunities to read science fiction were limted to either buying secondhand or getting whatever the library deemed worthy enough to get. You need bookstores like this, somewhere where you can go in casually and be surprised at what you find on its shelves. Yes, it is easy enough to get what you want from the internet, but it’s the books you didn’t realise you wanted but were glad to find that you can only encounter in a store like this.

R.I.P. De Boekenbeurs. Thanks for your service and I’ll miss you.

Into the glorious future of blogging made possible by Elon Musk

Disco Stu pointing at a graph of growing disco record sales from 1973 to 1976

Due to the glorious future Twitter is being dragged kicking and screaming into thanks to the inspired leadership of Elon Musk, suupergenius, UI thought it was time to give the ol’ blog a bit of attention again. Not that I haven’t been blogging semi-regularly, but whereas a decade ago I’d hit a post a day fairly regularly, the past couple of years I’ve lucky to get into double digits in a given month. Mostly focused on anime too, as for political and other writing Twitter was just too handy. But if Twitter is going away, will blogs make a comeback?

Doubt.

So much of the blogging infrastructure has been trashed over the past decade and a half, so much has been moved to centralised social media platforms that it’s unlikely we’ll ever return to the Golden Age of Blogging. If Twitter really does get destroyed by Musk, we’ll lose that as a platform as well though, so what are the alternatives? Hastily thrown up Twitter clones, single purpose Discord servers or Telegram channels, other social media like Instagram or *shudder* Tumblr, maybe even Mastodon, the technohippy anti-Twitter? None of them really suits my needs sso if I’m going to put effort in a new platform, it’s going to be my own.

Hence me culling the blogroll today. A bit of a slaughter there: so many blogs that stopped updating more than a decade ago, finally removed. Interestingly it’s the fandom blogs that proved the strongest. Perhaps anime weebs and sf nerds just have more staying power than politics geeks, cravingly following the masses to Twitter. A sad moment to be honest, seeing all those blogs that had so much time and effort put into them, just gone. Some were removed entirely, their servers no longer available, some on blogging sites had been taken over by Indonesian spamhouses, some just had their last post still displayed, October 11, 2015.

Regrowing these links will take time and it will never be as exciting or cool as it was the first time around, but that’s no reason not to try it. Won’t you join me in taking back ownership of your online presence?

Ten Years Later

That Sunday ten years ago had ended like most Sunday evenings: I’d written a post for my booklog (Omnitopia Dawn), farted about on the internet and had gone to bed before midnight. A few hours later I was woken up by a phone call from the hospital telling me Sandra had passed away.

Martin and Sandra

It wasn’t unexpected but it was still a surprise. I’d visited her in hospital only that evening, never expecting the end would come only hours after I’d left her. It was a surreal experience to take that taxi to the other side of Amsterdam and find her, well, gone. I knew that moment would come, but still wasn’t prepared for the reality of it. That day and the week after, I was just numb, just surviving day by day arranging the funeral. You never know how much your family can do for you until a moment like this. It was only once my parents and siblings had to go home again and I was alone, alone for the first time in years, that it all hit me. In a year after her death, not a day went by without crying. Dip into my posts for 2012 and you see how often I mention her.

Time heals all wounds, as the cliche says and it’s frightening how true this is. In the decade since she passed away she’s never been far from my memory, but the realities of day to day living means that raw pain is slowly ground down. As the physical reminders of her presence in our home slowly disappeared, the opportunities to be accidently reminded of her dwindle as well. You can’t keep grieving; at some point I made my peace with her death. Now it’s mostly moments like this that I’m mourning again. Despite this, she still isn’t far from my thoughts. Sandra shaped my politics (socialist), my tastes in literature (classic detectives), music (p-funk) and that influence is there to this day.

Hector and Sophia on Sandra's lap

We met the old fashioned way, trading sarcastic barbs on an IRC spinoff of the alt.fan.pratchett Usenet group back in spring of 2000. To be honest, first impressions weren’t good, but it soon turned out that this was our form of flirting. Chatting in the main channel became private chats between the two of us, became long phone calls — and wasn’t that scary that first time I called her– and finally, at Christmas 2000, Sandra came over to visit. That was a magical moment, it had started snowing only that day and waiting in a silent winter wonderland for that Eurolines bus to come in is one of my best memories. Getting used to each other and being with each other over the next few days was even better. In 2001 I tried to move to the UK but couldn’t get a job, so instead she moved to Amsterdam two years later. When we bought our house, we also got two kittens to keep the elderly stray cat we’d taken home from my parents company. Now only one of them is still alive (Sophie, on the left).

Our mutual love for Terry Pratchett’s books is what brought us together. We weren’t the only ones that got together through pTerry fandom; in our circle of friends there are a lot of people who met, shacked up, married and had children thanks to Pratchett. What set Sandra apart is that Pratchett also gave her the courage to die. She had had a bout of cancer that nearly killed her decades ago and as a result had barely functioning kidneys left. These finally packed up in 2008 and she needed a kidney transplant. It took a year of her slowly getting worse on dialysis before it could happen. As luck would have it, I was compatible with her and could be a donor, but both she and I needed to be in a good enough condition to undergo the operation. Two days before Christmas 2009 it happened. For me, the operation went smoothly and I was discharged on Christmas day. Sandra was less lucky.

Sandra looking skeptical

The next two years were an ordeal, as she combatted secondary infections and moved in and of hospital and worse, intensive care. Periods of recovery became fewer and fewer; the times she was home shorter and shorter. Those moments of hope followed by disappointment ate away at her and, if I’m honest, me as well. And then Terry Pratchett did one last thing for us: release a documentary about his decision on end his own life. Pratchett had been diagnosed with an aggressive form of early onset Alzheimers a few years ago and had decided that he would not let the disease determine his time of death. He would end his life on his terms, when he was still able to make the choice and before the disease ate away his personality. He made a documentary about this decision and we watched it together. It was this that gave the courage to do the same. In October she decided to stop all treatment and prepared for her death. We had a last family farewell that month and a few weeks later she passed away.

It took me a long time to get to peace with her decision. Still not sure I’m completely.