Cory Doctorow

I’m not sure I actually like Cory Doctorow, either as a blogger or an esseff writer. Boing Boing used to be on my blogroll until it got too up itself for me, and I’ve tried his fiction but haven’t managed to finish any of it. Part of what annoys me about him is his relentless self promotion, part his equally relentless, somewhat naive techno exuberance. The combination just sets my teeth on edge.

A good example was linked to by Making Light the other day, a short called “Other People’s Money“, which was written for Forbes. The excerpt below showcases what I dislike about Doctorow’s writing:

“You’d have thought I’d learned my lesson by then, but no, sir. I am the original glutton for punishment. After Bubble 2.0, I took my best coders, our CFO, and a dozen of our users and did a little health-care startup, brokering carbon-neutral medical travel plans to Fortune 500s. Today that sounds like old hat, but back then, it was sexy. No one seriously believed that we could get out from under the HMOs, but between Virgin’s cheap bulk-ticket sales and the stellar medical deals in Venezuela, Argentina and Cuba, it was the only cost-effective way. And once the IWWWW signed up 80 percent of the U.S. workforce through World of Starcraft guilds, no employer could afford to skimp on health insurance.
The word would go out during that night’s raids and by the morning, you’d have picket lines in front of every branch office.

The whole story is like that, one long infodump laced with buzzwords and jargon to show what Doctorow thinks could be our future. It’s near future and of a type that I should like, like much of Doctorow’s work, as it’s simular to what people like Neal Stephenson and Bruce Sterling have also written. There’s one great difference though, in that their stories were grounded in a political and sociological awareness that I find lacking with Doctorow.

Free rice

Free rice is another of those charitable websites, where your jumping through hoops is rewarded by a tiny donation to a good cause. Usually this involves pushing buttons, but the people behind this site have been smart enough to make a proper game out of it. You’re asking to guess the meaning of an uncommon word and if you guess right, you get to donate ten whole grains of rice to the UN! The longer you get it right, the harder it gets of course. It’s a very addictive game to those of us who are fond of words and vocabulary anyway, playing on the innate geeky loving of learning and competitiveness.

Nevertheless, it still reminds me of China Miéville’s short story “An End to Hunger” with its sarcastic putdown of such sites. If the people behind it are so concerned with ending world hunger, surely there are more effective ways of doing so? Because this way, it’s only a p.r. gimmick, a way for the companies sponsoring the site and the people playing the game both to parade their own goodness.

Does that mean you shouldn’t play their game? Not as long as you know it is a game, a put-on.

The Tudors

If there’s one thing the BBC just cannot do, it’s making trailers for their tv shows that do not fill you with a brightly burning hatred for the show in question after the second time you’ve seen the trailer. Doesn’t matter whether the programme itself is good or not, because the trailers are so annoying and they’re shown so often (even thirty seconds before the show in question comes on) that you cannot help but loathe it. And when the trailers are promoting something that is going to be awful, the trailers are even worse. Such was the case for The Tudors, BBC2’s latest mock-historical costumes ‘n sex drama. You knew it was going to be bad because the trailer showed all sort of dark! dramatic! scenery chewing, interspersed with pseudoporn, and the lead actor did that stupid “talking normally THEN SHOUTING bit” that bad tv actors thinks shows tension, but instead just makes them look like a berk.

We’ve watched the series a bit since it came on because we always catch it switching from Have I got News for You on BBC1 to Q.I. on BBC2, because we keep forgetting there’s half an hour inbetween them. While watching it, S— remarked that it seemed made for the American market because a) dumbed down, b) overdramatic and c) lots of filler that could be cut for commercials. Well, surprise surprise, it turned out she was right, Daily Mail tells us. This being the Mail, there’s plenty of sexy photos of it inbetween telling us how sexed up and awful it is:

Modern radiators, Tarmac driveways, concrete bollards and Victorian carriages have all made appearances in the tenpart series set in the 16th century.

Made by Showtime, a U.S. production company, The Tudors appeared on American screens before being bought by BBC2. Henry VIII is played by Jonathan Rhys Meyers of Bend It Like Beckham fame.

Last night, Leanda de Lisle, a Tudor biographer, said: “Overall the series is badly written with an extremely cheap feel to it.

“It is hugely disappointing. With inaccuracies in almost every sentence, the BBC is dumbing down the Tudor period.”

She said the anachronisms would be acceptable only if the drama “rang true” – and this hadn’t been the case.

She added: “The characters talk in completely unnatural ways, addressing their own family members as “Anne Boleyn” or “Mary Boleyn” so that we, the stupid audience, understand who they’re supposed to be.

“Henry VIII was exceedingly powerful, both politically and physically, but Rhys Meyers is pretty, rather than macho and thus completely unconvincing.”

The Tudors is only the worst recent example of the BBC’s recent tendency to sex up and dumb down its historical dramas, either to attract more viewers or to be able to sell it on to the American market. Any educative values still presents in these shows is watered down to homeopathic levels in the process, losing much of the justification for them. These series are supposed to teach some history in an enjoyable manner, but unless you’ve got a fetish for “medieval” costume cosplay, you’ll neither enjoy The Tudors nor learn anything from it.

People who really need to stop goddamn whining now

Malkin

  1. Christians who think their beliefs excuse them from doing their goddam job, but who do not expect this to cause them problems, like this fucker. No, it’s not religious discrimination if you get fired for not doing your job properly, you asshole.
  2. Police who complain about judges’ decisions, no matter how awful you think they are. It’s not your job to decide on what constitutes a fitting punishment, it’s to catch bad guys and hopefully not shoot too many innocent Brazilians in the process.
  3. I was going to say, “anybody who thinks slandering a twelve year old is a-okay but who get their panties in a bunch when somebody twits Bush, but I think i’ll just amend that to the motherfucking Malkin“.

Balanced News

There’s a good report up on Medialens of how something that looks at first sight to be a balanced newsreport, on further investigation,isn’t. No prizes if you guessed this might have something to do with climate change, and in particular, that High Court judge and his supposed finding of “nine errors” in Al gore’s An Inconvenient Truth. The BBC did their usual piece on this, by interviewing the involved parties, but they let themselves been snookered as they never looked into how the complainant, Stuart Dimmock, a lorry driver and school governor could afford to bring his complaint all the way to the High Court. If they had, they would’ve found that he was sponsored by the climate change skeptic New Party, itself sponsored by Scottish millionaire Robert Durward. By not reporting this in their interviews with Dimmock, the BBC therefore provided a clearly false picture of this court case while still adhering to the doctrine of “balance”.

This is only one example of a widespread practise, not just at the BBC but in all news media, where instead of journalists trying to determine the truth behind the surface story, only the claims and counterclaims of the involved parties are reported. This is not necessarily a bad thing; in politics especially it is often hard to objectively determine the truth of a story, or the story is about the conflicting interpretations of government and opposition for a given incident. It’s then that a summation of claim and counterclaim is justified, but not when relevant facts are left out of the story.

But even when this sort of reporting is justified, a story can be balanced and still be unfair. An example of this was on display in a news item I heard last night on the Radio 4 six oçlock news bulletin. The story was about the Scottish government’s opposition against a replacement for the UK’s current Trident based nuclear deterrent. since the Trident submarines are based in Faslane in Scotland, making the country therefore a nuclear target, it’s clearly a legitimate concern of the Scottish governement, even though technically it falls outside their jurisdiction.

On the BBC news however this was framed with a soundbyte from Wendy Alexander, the leader of the Labour opposition in the Scottish Parliament, who said she didn’t want English politicians speaking for Scotland on matters like healthcare and therefore Scottish politicians should not speak out about English or British matters either. This was immediately followed by a question from the BBC reporter to the Scottish National Pary’s spokesperson on whether the SNP did not go too far in its opposition to Trident replacement. With that, even though both sides, Labour and SNP, got their say, the bias of the story was clearly in favour of Labour; but you wouldn’t know that it was biased unless you paid close attention.

It’s a borderline dishonest way of reporting on stories, and it’s far more common than you think. Much of the reputation of a Jeremy Paxman or a John Humpries for being “tough”, it seems to me, is due to mock aggresive oneway questioning like this, where only the weaker party is attacked like this. The BBC may pride itself on being independent, but in important matters it will almost always take the side of the vested interests, the establishment.