War not going well for Israel

The war is not going well for the Israelis is it? One of the Israeli warships blockading Lebalon was hit yesterday, killing four sailors by either an “explosives-laden drone” (the story Friday) or an “Iran-manufactured C-802 missile” (according to the Israeli army today and very convenient it is too in the ongoing quest to subject Iran to regime change). This is not supposed to happen and the instinctive impulse to blame it on Iranese supplied supermissiles is telling: Hezbollah is not supposed to be this smart, so the only way they could’ve damaged a superior Israeli warship must’ve been with a supermissile supplied by somebody else, somebody more respectable. Twenty years ago the USSR would’ve been blamed, today it’s Iran. The ship btw is very likely a Eilat class large missile corvette, the largest ships Israel has in service…

At the same time, the Palestinians showed they were not stupid either, when “Hamas gunmen” blew a hole in the wall separating Gaza from Egypt, allowing around a 1,000 Palestinians caught on the wrong side of the border to finally go home. Again, this is not according to the script. Palestinians are supposed to suffer whatever indignities Israel inflicts on them, not find a way around them!

Meanwhile, the Israeli tactics are the same tactics that failed to work in Lebanon last time and since then similar tactics have spectacularly failed for the Americans in Afghanistan and Iraq: aerial and artillery bombardments to destroy infrastructure and supposed enemy strongholds combined with blockading actions and a reluctance to get too deep into enemy territory and suffer casualties. The strategy behind these tactics for the Israelis is to bully the Palestinian Authority in Gaza and the Lebanese government respectively into leaning on the militants in their areas: “if we make their life miserable enough, they’re bound to hand back our captured soldiers”. So far that does not seem to work.

There’s no real expectance that it will work. The militants in question are barely touched by the bombing, instead it’s the civilian population that suffers. Worse for Israel, the bombardments have the opposite effect than they’re intended to have: they serve to bind the population of Gaza tighter to Hamas and in Lebanon tighter to Hezbollah. It is not as if this was unexpected, so what were the Israeli commanders thinking? It may just be stupidity born from arrogance, something not new to the Israelis, who after all have had more than half a century of continuing military succes, which leads them to underestimate their enemies. Or it may be something more.

There’s a recurring tendency within Israeli strategic thinking to go for the big, conclusive strike that will destroy once and for all their enemies capabilities to attack Israel. In 1982 this thinking led to the invasion of Lebanon, with the idea being that if only South Lebanon was under Israeli control, attacks on the north of Israel would cease. It would be a quick action, with a friendly puppet regime to rule the region backed up by a small Israeli force afterwards and no more worries. Instead, they got sucked further and further into the country and had to remain in South Lebanon themselves until finally withdrawn in 2000. In the process they helped create Hezbollah, but nevermind.

Whatif this kind of thinking is again in fashion? What if the Israeli army wants to use this crisis to launch a proper war, not just targeting Hamas in the Occuppied Territories and Hezbollah in Lebanon, but also getting rid of her last two state enemies, Syria and Iran, the alleged sponsors of Hezbollah/Hamas? If the Palestinians have no more state sponsors, Palestinian resistance will collapse, Israel will not have to fear anymore suicide bombings and can do what it wants in the Occupied Territories. Yes, not very realistic, but realism is often absent when these decisions are made (viz. Iraq).

In any event, there is little hope this war is going to stop soon. Israel in particular is now in a position in which it either has to scale up its efforts to win it, or withdraw and lose face. In its military history, the moments that it has chosen the second option are rare.

Boycott Israel

Boycott Israel sticker

Why boycott Israel? Because it’s a racist regime, comparable to Apartheid South Africa at its worst. If any illusions about the Palestinian Territories as a new Bantustan still persist, surely this weeks attack on the Gaza strip should have dispelled them. Israel will not change its ways until it is forced to do so. Hence a boycott.

Eddie Campbell

Most of you will know Eddie Campbell, if you know him at all, from his work with Alan Moore on From Hell, Moore’s magnus opus on Jack the Ripper and the birth of the 20th century, amongst other things. What you may not be awareof is that Campbell has had a much longer career than that and is not just an artist, but a talented writer in his own right.

His best know solo work is probably Bacchus, a long running series starring the Greek god of alcohol and his adventures in the twentieth century. The centuries have not been kind to Bacchus and he’s now little more than a wino, though a wino who looks uncannily like Corto Maltese. The drawing is semi-realistic, more in the style of Milton Caniff or Hugo Pratt, though with periods of Kirbyesque excess. The stories are somewhat meandering, with interchanging episodes of high voltage action and more quiet, slice of life drama. Various other surviving Greek gods show up from time to time as well. The early stories are somewhat on the rough side still, but get much better over time. The best Bacchus book you can get is probably King Bacchus, with Bacchus is king of the Castle and Frog pub, which has seceded from the United Kingdom and declared its independence. The followup volumes are also quite good. But really, no Bacchus book is a bad buy, even the early, rougher volumes are worth getting.

Next to Bacchus, there’s Alec, which is basically a slightly fictionalised autobiography. Campbell has been doing these stories for years and unlike many cartoonists he’s actually had an interesting life. Born in Scotland, quite bright, worked for years in various blue collar jobs, started cartooning, lots of drunk adventures (notice a theme), got married, moved to Australia, got kids, settled down. Alec is the longest running series Campbell has been doing, having done Alec stories since he started drawing comics. What’s impressive about them is that, again unlike other cartoonists, he knows when to move the focus from his own life to that of the people around him, without coming across as a voyeur. Much of it feels like the sort of stories you’d tell your mates in the pub, only much better.

Campbell’s artwork is excellent, at its best in black and white I find. As said he is very much in the style of Hugo Pratt or Milton Caniff, though immediately recognisable as his own. He has an eye for small details and knows when to put in details and when to leave them out. The small samples here really do not do his work justice; the best way to sample his work is to get one of his books and
just start reading. Any good comic book store or library should have at least some.

Now to do a Mike Sterling and do a half post of linky goodness:

The art of reviewing

No matter how crap I find my reviews the next day, I can’t help but think that at least I’m still doing reviews, rather than ill-disguised hitpieces. The English socalled quality newspapers especially have a nasty habit of abusing their bookreviews; here are two from the supposedly liberal Observer that annoyed me today

The first comes via commenter Dearkitty and is an Observer review of Richard Ingrams’ The Life and Adventures of William Cobbett. What annoyed me especially here was the opening paragraph:

If William Cobbett hadn’t existed, few people today would feel the need to invent him. Best known for Rural Rides, his socio-lyrical tour of England in the 1820s, Cobbett’s early life is a chaos of politics, tangled up in the kind of issues which are world-shattering to those who live through them but forgotten in a generation.

I can’t stand the jocular matey tone in which Cobbett is dismissed here. It also shows an uncanny lack of history to dismiss the cause of parliamentary reform and extended voting rights for the common man as “the kind of issues” that are “forgotten in a generation”. The rest of the review is almost as awful, written to template: “catchy” opening, some discussion of the subject of the book done with not too much accuracy, with less than half the review actually talking about the book itself and never actually coming out in judgement of it.

The other review is more vile and more dangerous, a hatchet job on Noam Chomsky, which “Lenin” neatly dissected.
Here it is the last two paragraphs that got on my tits:

But what I find most noxious about Chomsky’s argument is his desire to create a moral – or rather immoral – equivalence between the US and the greatest criminals in history. Thus on page 129, comparing a somewhat belated US conversion to the case for democracy in Iraq after the failure to find WMD, Chomsky claims: ‘Professions of benign intent by leaders should be dismissed by any rational observer. They are near universal and predictable, and hence carry virtually no information. The worst monsters – Hitler, Stalin, Japanese fascists, Suharto, Saddam Hussein and many others – have produced moving flights of rhetoric about their nobility of purpose.’

Which leads to a question: is that really what you see, Mr Chomsky, from the window of your library at MIT? Is it the stench of the gulag wafting over the Charles River? Do you walk in fear of persecution and murder for expressing your dissident views? Or do you make a damn good living out of it? The faults of the Bush administration will not be changed by books such as Failed States. They will be swept away by ordinary, decent Americans in the world’s greatest – if flawed and selfish – democracy going to the polls.

There are several things to object to here: the deliberate and stupid misreading of Chomsky’s argument in the worst possible light, the histrionic fashion in which he accuses Chomsky of hypocrisie –“is that really what you see, Mr Chomsky” — “Is it the stench of the gulag wafting over the Charles River?” — “Do you walk in fear of persecution and murder for expressing your dissident views? Or do you make a damn good living out of it?” and finally, the great slobbering sucking up of those last two sentences. It fair turns the stomach.

It turns the stomach even more so, because it is the Blair defence. Everytime Blair has been confronted by angry members of the public and is held accountable for his actions towards Iraq, he comes out with the same old line, that you are allowed to your opinion because you are living in a country, in which you have the right to criticise your government (nervous hand gesutre, sweaty forehead) and should the people of Iraq not have that right?

Not that anyone is ever convinced by this pap, but it is a nice way to claim the moral high ground and any misdeeds are swept under the carpet – never mind Iraq is in a perpeptual civil war and embassy employees cannot reveal who they work for without being killed, at least the Iraqies are free now. In the same way, as long as Chomsky is not dragged from his office and burned in front of M.I.T., clearly his criticisms of the United States are without ground. Because this great United States is still a democracy and that excuses any and all misdeeds, which will anyway surely be resolved by the voters in the next elections.