ThE lEsSeR eViL

You’d have to be a terminal wally to fall for this shite

British lefties who say they won’t vote for Starmer: I understand where you’re coming from, I do. Just one small thing, if you could just help me with that: what the actual fuck are you talking about?

This is the childish view of politics as sport, where the only thing that matters is that the man in the boot stamping on your face wears a red rather than a blue rosette. Where all that matters is “Tories out” with no thought at all about if what replaces them is any better. Labour and Starmer have done their level best to signal that they will be continuity Tories, but they wear the right colour tie so let’s get them in power. Politics reduced to pulling the lever for the ‘correct’ party with no demands on its leadership, no accountability, just some magic faith that it will all come good once they’re in power and just ignore all the lies and broken promises.

So far, so liberal, but it’s worse. You’re being urged to vote for a party ruled by the same people that deliberately sabotaged its chances because they disliked its previous leader. You’re expected to vote for the people who called you antisemitic, traitorous scum, who sicced the press and the BBC on you for just wanting a bit more equality, a bit more justice. Even after you surrendered and you voted for Starmer as leader just to make the bullying stop, it didn’t end. Now it’s the party itself calling its own members filthy peasant oiks that better vote for it if they know what’s good for them and then bugger off.

Who would vote for that? They told you to fuck off, so if you have any dignity, do so.

Or we could stay stewing in the same traffic jams, just electrified

Amy Westervelt in The Intercept talks about the need to not just mindlessly replace fossil energy with its sustainable equivalent, but also think about ways to reduce demand:

IN 2019, THEA RIOFRANCOS was splitting her time between researching the social and environmental impacts of lithium mining in Chile and organizing for a rapid energy transition away from fossil fuels in the United States. A political science professor at Providence College and member of the Climate and Community Project, Riofrancos was struck by the contrast: Lithium is essential to the batteries that make electric vehicles and renewable energy work, but mining inflicts its own environmental damage. “Here I am in Chile, in the Atacama Desert, seeing these mining-related harms, and then there I go in the U.S. advocating for a rapid transition. How do I align these two goals?” Riofrancos said. “And is there a way to have a less extractive energy transition?”

It’s an American centric article, but the same arguments apply to the Netherlands and Europe too. Even ‘clean’ energy has massive ecological costs and everything we can do to lessen those by lessen the need for it helps. Improve public transport rather than just sit in the same traffic jam as you do now, only in an electric car. The problem is that even just swapping out fossil fuels for solar is beyond our governments, still happier pushing more billions of subsidy towards Shell or talk about starting up gas production in Groningen again than even get close to serious about investing in wind or solar energy. The Dutch government even going so far as to pretend it can build two new nuclear plants in the next decade.

Anything beyond “the same way we do things now, but sustainable(ish)” seems clear utopian thinking to me.

Love My Life — Friday Funnies

Yamaji Ebine’s Love My Life starts with Ichiko Izumiya coming out to her father as a lesbian, only to have the tables turned on her:

Ichiko asking her father if he was surprised at her being lesbian. He answers that he was as he thought that she sure was the child of her parents. Turns out he is gay as well

As it turns out, Ichiko’s father and deceased mother were both gay, best friends and decided to raise a child together. Her mother had asked her father never to mention this, but now she herself turned out to queer herself, he saw no reason not to. And while they were married and living together, they each still had their other, gay lovers. Coming out is difficult enough already, but having to also digest your parents’ own secret gay history must be doubly so.

Ellie talking about her father who would lock her in a psychiatric ward if he found her breat to breast with another woman

Processing the realities of her father’s gayness is just one of the things Ichiko has to wrestle with in this twelve chapter, single volume story. Eighteen years old, Ichiko is in her first relationship with Ellie Jyojima, three years older than her, a college student studying law. Unlike Ichiko, Ellie has been in several relationships before, both with men — before she realised she was lesbian — and women. Ellie is less fortunate than Ichiko, coming from a traditional family with a father who finds homosexuality “a mental illness”. The realities of having to deal with homophobia and the need for people to stay in the closet to their family, friends or work is a red thread through the story. It’s not just Ellie having to deal with hiding her queerness from her father or when running across a male ex-lover by accident, but also the more mundane realisation that people would see them as just friends when going out together.

Take-chan feels trapped being seen as a straight man and longs to come out

Or, the other side of the coin, people gossiping in college about Ichiko and Take-chan, a gay male friend, as obviously going out because they spent time together. He feels frustrated, trapped at being made to play the role of a straight man, but also doesn’t feel courageous enough to make that step out of the closet. Having overheard how people talk about gay men, he’s in no hurry to leave its safety and who can blame him. Instead he shares his frustrations and concerns with Ichiko, who does the same with him as well as her girlfriend. I like their friendship, that sort of outsider allyship that is quite common among queer people, sharing the same sort of experiences living in a heteronormative society. In general it’s good to see more queer people inhabiting this story than just Ichiko and Ellie. Take-chan, his boyfriend, as well as Ichiko’s father’s boyfriend, the old girlfriend of her mother Ichiko runs into, now in a new relationship, even a bald headed girl Ichiko has a short crush on in a later chapter, all drift and out of the story as required, all adding to the verisimilitude of it. This not some fantasy world where everybody is queer, nor the sort of story where only the protagonist and their love interest is.

Take-chan feels trapped being seen as a straight man and longs to come out

What also adds to the realism of Love My Life is that Ichiko and Ellie have a healthy sex life. It’s established from the start that they fuck and they like it, that part of their attraction to each other is physical and neither is embarrassed about this. It’s a refreshingly adult take that never felt exploitative or done for the sake of fan service. It’s refreshing when so many yuri manga are about high school romances where hand holding is the worst the characters get up to.

Caption: can you feel my hands and my warmth? as Ellie goes down on Ichiko

This is a very dialogue heavy manga as you may have figured out, but Yamaji Ebine’s art should not go unmentioned. With such a personal story it’s unsurprising that most of the art’s focus is on the characters, rather than the world they inhibit. Backgrounds are often left out when unnecessary, only when it’s necessary to establish a location do we get establishing shots, more functional than artistic. There aren’t the exaggerated emotions, few if any of the comedy deformations you might expect from a manga. Yamaji Ebine has a knack of nailing a character’s look with just a few lines: of course the driven, law student Ellie would have an almost Patrick Nagel-esque, sharp hairstyle. Of course the more sheltered and naive Ichiko looks a bit more fluffy in both hair and body.

Love My Life was serialised in Feel Young, a monthly magazine aimed at young women, in 2000 and 2001 before being released as a single volume manga. According to the afterword, Yamaji Ebine “this is where I began my career”. Although she had debuted several years before, she had stopped creating manga until Ichiko popped fully formed from her mind while reading a book by a female American writer. As far as I’m aware it has never been officially translated in English. Currently the only way to read it in English is through Mangadex. I hope somebody (Seven Seas?) does pick it up at some point; this is too good to languish in obscurity overseas.

Not sure what to think about this

The Washington Post looking into the data sets Google uses to train its chatbots and some surprising results popped up:

A screenshot from the article showing cloggie.org is present in the data set with 230 tokes and rank 11,780,115

As The Post put it:

To look inside this black box, we analyzed Google’s C4 data set, a massive snapshot of the contents of 15 million websites that have been used to instruct some high-profile English-language AIs, called large language models, including Google’s T5 and Facebook’s LLaMA. (OpenAI does not disclose what datasets it uses to train the models backing its popular chatbot, ChatGPT)
The Post worked with researchers at the Allen Institute for AI on this investigation and categorized the websites using data from Similarweb, a web analytics company. About a third of the websites could not be categorized, mostly because they no longer appear on the internet. Those are not shown.
We then ranked the remaining 10 million websites based on how many “tokens” appeared from each in the data set. Tokens are small bits of text used to process disorganized information — typically a word or phrase.

Because the article kindly included a search bar I found out my website is also included in the data set, with some 230 tokens. It would be interesting to see what exactly was included in those 230 tokens from the more than two decades of rambling contained in this site. Sadly, that’s not provided here. Nevertheless, an interesting look in the data used in training socalled AI programmes and its limitations.

Hillsborough 34 years later

On the anniversary of the Hillsborough disaster, in which 96 people died as the result of the authorities disdain for football supporters, an excellent interview with Ian Byrne MP, himself one of the survivors:

What we’re fighting for is a legacy. We’re doing that with everything we’re involved in, from ‘The Real Truth’ Legacy Project to the Hillsborough Law Now campaign. It’s about achieving a legacy, because we got the truth about Hillsborough but we never got the justice. From educating people to campaigning for legal changes, we want to ensure that survivors of disasters and victims’ families never again have to face the state with a blindfold on and their hands tied behind their back.
[…]
We are campaigning for Hillsborough to be on the national curriculum and to educate people about it because it resonates. The same playbook for state cover-ups has been used time and time again. Look at Grenfell; the victims of that disaster would have expected the state to be on their side, as we did at Hillsborough, and that it would seek truth and justice and ensure nothing like that could happen again. But it didn’t. There are so many instances like that.
[…]
The Fans Supporting Foodbanks network was born from Liverpool and Everton fans working together. That solidarity has its roots in working together over Hillsborough. The idea of two clubs coming together in times of strife and grief is something we as a city did with Rhys Jones and Hillsborough. Fans Supporting Foodbanks is a natural offshoot of that.
[…]
With Fans Supporting Foodbanks, we’ve had Millwall and West Ham fans, Manchester United and Manchester City fans, and Rangers and Celtic fans working together to collect food for those in need. We’re trying to build on that ethos. What unites us as working-class football fans is far greater than what divides us.